Right now, the government is shut down. You won't really notice until Monday, but on Monday people will start
to notice. DACA expires 6 weeks from Monday. So on Monday, if we haven't done anything, the government will be shut
down, and we have 43 days to go until DACA. I think we need to fund the
government on a short-term basis--maybe it is February 9--and then we
spend the next 3 weeks working on an agreement on defense, an agreement
on disaster relief, and an agreement on border security and DACA. For Democrats who are worried they don't have leverage, you have
plenty of leverage without shutting down the government. For example,
there are two Republicans who oppose short-term spending in general. Then you have several Republican Members who oppose any longer term
spending without defense spending increases. In essence, this worry
that you have that they are going to fund the government for just 6
months and walk away from DACA--there are at least five Republicans who
are going to vote no on that, several because of defense and two
because of short-term spending. Then add to that, there are at least
three other Republican Members--myself being one of them--who will have
a lot of trouble voting for a long-term spending plan that doesn't
include disaster relief. That alone gives you leverage to ensure that
not only do those issues need to be dealt with, but all three of them
would have to be dealt with in order for there to be any long-term deal
that forecloses the leverage you want. You have another piece of leverage: The President needs to fulfill
his campaign promise, which Americans supported at the ballot box:
Build a wall. He knows he can't do that without a DACA deal. So,
really, both sides here have leverage. But as long as the government is
shut down, we are wasting valuable time. Monday could have been a day that people met and hashed out key
details of DACA. Instead, Monday will probably be all about the
shutdown--and maybe Tuesday and maybe Wednesday. We are wasting time we
do not have. Finally, as for DACA, what is the way forward on that? There are a
lot of ideas going around. Here is what I would say to you: The
baseline in the core of any agreement is one that basically codifies
DACA, in essence, deals with the President's decision to suspend the
Executive order on it and funds in a way that can guarantee continued
funding the President's immigration enforcement plan. That is the core. You codify DACA, and you do something to ensure that the wall is going
to be built and that they can't come back and cancel the funding. Then
the Senate can go into an open amendment process and debate any
additional matters you want put in there. For example, maybe there is a
deal that, instead of codifying DACA alone, it actually creates a
pathway to citizenship under DACA, but it eliminates not just DACA
applicants but future applicants from being able to sponsor parents. I
am not saying that it will pass, but that might be a debate that
happens. Even if you can't reach 60 votes on any of these amendments people
are offering, even if all those amendments fail, in the end, you are at
least left with a bill that secures our border and gives permanent
certainty to close to 700,000 people who currently are registered under
DACA. As Benjamin Franklin said after he agreed to the Constitution in
1787: We may all be left with a law in which none of us got everything
we wanted, but everyone got something that they needed. The DACA recipients would have the certainty of knowing that they can
stay in America legally for the rest of their lives, and perhaps future
Congresses and future Presidents may build upon that, and the President
will have achieved a signature campaign promise and achieved something
Republicans--and many Democrats--have been promising to do but have
failed to deliver for over 15 years; that is, to secure the border and
build a wall. There is a way forward on all of these things. If we remember how our
system works, we can start making it happen, but I think it will
require us to accept what it takes to make progress in a constitutional
Republic.
Keywords matched
immigration border security DACA