Session #115 · 2017–19

Speech #CREC-2018-01-20-pt1-PgS359-6_t102

It is immoral to deport someone to a country they have never really lived in. You were 2 years old when you came from Honduras, you don't even speak Spanish, you don't know anybody there, and they are going to send you there--it just doesn't feel right. It is my deepest belief that if DACA expires and 700,000 young adults who have spent the majority of their lives among us are forced to leave this country, I think it would be a dark stain on our history. I think future generations would look back at that and say that was a terrible thing those people did back then. I think we have more support for what I just said in the Republican Party than we have ever had in the 7 years that I have been here. But I have to be fair and I want to be frank. It is also a mistake to overreach on the other side of this argument. It is fair to argue that we should deal with DACA because it is the moral and compassionate thing to do. It is fair to argue that dealing with DACA is in our national interest, but it is a big mistake to demand a right that does not exist. There is no right to illegally immigrate to any country on the planet. No one has a right to DACA, but dealing with DACA is the right thing to do. I think it is also overreaching to insist that not only must DACA recipients be accommodated, but we also have to accommodate their parents. Maybe because I personally know so many people under these circumstances, I am personally open to figuring out something that allows their parents to stay, especially if the children are minors. I understand that is not a majority position in my party, and I have to be honest with you that I believe that if we take the position around here that we are not accepting any deal unless it takes care of both the DACA recipient and the parent--if that is the hard position we adopt and people aren't willing to move off of it, I think there may be no deal at all, and that means that neither the recipients of DACA nor the parents will have anything. By the way, I also think it is overreach to oppose a border wall because you find it symbolically offensive. First, America has a right and, more importantly, a responsibility to protect its borders and enforce its laws. Second, there is not going to be a DACA deal of any kind without a wall, period. Donald Trump is not going to sign, cannot sign, and will not sign a bill that doesn't have real enforcement. That is a fact.
Keywords matched
border wall immigrate DACA

Classification

Sentiment
Mixed
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Humanitarian Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
MARCO RUBIO
Party
R
Chamber
S
State
FL
Gender
—
Date
2018-01-20
Speech ID
CREC-2018-01-20-pt1-PgS359-6_t102
Paragraph
#8
← Prev Next →