Session #103 · 1993–95

Speech #1030158167

However. this process does not lend itself to processing a large outflow of boat persons. It became necessary to discontinue it after the boat flow increased so dramatically following the OAS embargo which was instituted several weeks after Aristide was overthrown. A third alternative would be to establish a refugee processing facility "somewhere in the region." to which all rescued boat people could be taken for screening. Now. such a processing facility should be operated by the U.N. High Commissioner for Refugees to ensure a credible screening process. Those who are found not to have a wellfounded fear of political persecution should be returned to their homeland. while those who do present a wellfounded fear of persecution if they were to return could be resettled in third countries or allowed to remain in the processing center until it is safe to return. If thirdcountry resettlement were required. the United States should accept its fair share of these true refugees. And this alternative. of course. is the most desirable solution to the problem. It should be pursued without delay. Both the Bush administration and the Clinton administration have "dropped the ball" on the establishment of a regional processing center. Both administrations claimed that no country in the region was willing to have such a facility established in its territory. and that was. under the previous administration. and is. under this one. "a copout." What these two administrations were really saying is that they were not willing to expend the foreign policy capital so clearly needed to convince one or more of our neighbors in the region to provide the location for a refugee processing facility. There is a very good reason why such a processing center should not be established on U.S. territory. We have demonstrated over and over again in this body and in the Congress that there is no such thing as a "temporary" status or a "temporary" stay in the United States. Every time we have allowed any group of undocumented aliens or "refugees." particularly a group from a Western Hemisphere nation. to remain in the country "temporarily." we have found they stay permanently. We just do not have the stomach to carry out our "temporary safe haven" policies with the use of enforced departure when it is safe for the aliens to return. We will not deport people after the "horror" has ended. And all of those persons and. of course. their legal counsel take advantage of these policies. and you may be darned sure of it. In fact. the workload for American immigration lawyers in this area is. as we say in the trade. "significant." Nicaraguans who came here in the 1970s during the fighting between the Samoza forces and the Sandinistas are still in the United States. After free elections were held in their country. Salvadorans who poured into the United States in the 1980s and who were given temporary protected status in this country remain right here. although the fighting has ended and the democratic elections have been successfully held in their homelands. The Poles who sought "temporary" protection here during the repression of the solidarity movement remain riveted in this country although their original leader. Lech Walesa. has now been President of that country for years. How can this be? I believe that all fairminded observers must agree that "temporary" safe havens have just not worked. you cannot have fled Poland during the time when they were crushing solidarity and stay now that the leader of solidarity is leading the country. If you were really a refugee. you would go back. I have not heard of anybody that wanted to go back. In El Salvador they came here because five factions were going in and chopping each other to pieces.
Identified stereotypes
Generalization that temporary safe havens do not work because people stay permanently.
Keywords matched
undocumented immigration refugees refugee temporary protected status Refugees

Classification

Target group
Also mentioned
Nicaraguans Salvadorans Poles
Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
⚠️ Yes
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Economic threat Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
ALAN SIMPSON
Party
R
Chamber
S
State
WY
Gender
M
Date
1994-05-02
Speech ID
1030158167
Paragraph
#2
← Prev Next →