Many would die on the voyage. Many more would reach Florida. Such a heavy flow of unauthorized aliens into the United States would add to the economic burden of immigration which Florida already claims to be unbearable. And it would. I surely believe. further seriously erode public support for a historically generous immigration and refugee policy. However. I do certainly acknowledge that it is difficult to defend our Haitian policy in the face of this countrys wholly uneven and ragged record with regard to refugees. The Refugee Act of 1980. which was crafted by our good colleague from Massachusetts. Senator KENNEDYone of the first projects that he and I became involved with in our work in immigration and refugee and asylum. a continuing laborcontemplated a casebycase examination of each applicant for refugee status in order to determine whether or not that person had a wellfounded fear of political persecution. You cannot be a refugee or an asylee unless you have a wellfounded fear of persecution based on race. religion. national origin. or membership in a political or social organization. period. We are not talking about economic refugees or political refugees of some other order. Despite the clarity of the refugee law. we annually admit approximately 50.000 persons from the former Soviet Union. who are presumed to be refugees simply because they are members of specific religions. We accept nearly every person who can make it to the United States from Cuba. no questions asked. simply because Cuba is a Communist country. We admit scores of thousands of southeast Asians who are treated as refugees not because they have fled political persecution but in most cases only because they have relatives in the United States. And then we offer green cards to tens of thousands of Chinese students who were in the United States at the time of the Tiananmen Square incident and claim they can never safely return home again. although many thousands of them return to China for visits during their school vacations. Our refugee policy is simply "gimmicked" to death. And that does make it highly difficult to defend the Haitian boat person policy. although I still do believe it is the correct policy under all the circumstances. If the President should determine that a current interdiction policy does not provide a reasonable opportunity for a person with a crediblecredibleclaim of asylum to be heard. what else could be done? I believe the three most likely alternatives are these: One. we could allow Haitians to enter the United States to present their asylum claims. In my opinion. this should be considered only as a very last resort. Such a policy would not be in the national interest. It would encourage hundreds of thousands of Haitians to attempt illegal entry into the United States. and it would do great harm and damage. in my opinion. to public support for our current. most generous immigration and refugee policy. A second alternative would be to resume screening of the Haitian boat people aboard the Coast Guard cutters which rescue them. That was our policy for many years. and it worked well.
Identified stereotypes
Generalization that refugees from certain countries are not genuinely seeking asylum but are exploiting the system.