Session #98 · 1983–85

Speech #980042956

Somehow we are .iminished as a nation by their existence. While I understand fully the purpose of the Senator in offering this amendment. it is consistent with his views. and I respect that greatlyand it is a view I share. reducing Federal welfare costs at a time of unacceptably large Federal deficits but I fear that such an amendment will tend to continue the existence of this fearful subsociety that I describe within our Nation. We must recall that many people who immigrate to this country. those who receive green cards and permanent resident alien statusand that is what a green card is. permanent resident alien statusdo not necessarily become naturalized citizens. In fact. an extraordinary percentage of Mexicans who have the opportunity and do have legal green cards never seek naturalization. If I recall correctly. that figure was 80 percent. Eighty percent of the Mexicans with the legal green card do not go on to seek naturalization. They would rather retain the green card. So. under our Constitution and our laws. it is not necessary for them to naturalize in order to enjoy almost all the benefits and protections of this country. other than the right to vote. Nevertheless. these people do become an integral part of our society. serving in the Armed Forces. contributing in many other ways to the United Statestaxpayers. income taxpayersso to permanently withhold Federal welfare benefits from those aliens who are legalized but never naturalized would perpetuate. in effect. another kind of subclass within the society. That is the very thing we are attempting to eliminate by the legalization program. The provisions presently in the bill restricts the right of legalized aliens to federally funded welfare benefits for 3 yearsthat is in there. They are restricted there from any welfare benefits for 3 years while they are in temporary residence status. and for another 3 years if they are in permanent residence status. I think that is eminently fair. It is wholly in keeping with our present immigration law. which provides that immigrants to this country should not be likely to become public charges. In fact. a person who seeks to naturalize cannot do so if they possibly would be a public charge. nor. I think if they might become public charges after immigration. They are here as economic migrants. They are working. usually single. coming here for one reason. to work. They are not fleeing persecution. they are not refugees. They are economic migrants. The magnet is jobs. and therefore they are working. So I think what we have done with benefits to temporary resident aliens and permanent resident aliens. providing emergency medical assistance together with disability. if that is required. is eminently fair. To extend the denial of those benefits indefinitely. until the time of naturalization. I think. would perpetuate societal conflict within the country. I urge rejection of the amendment.
Identified stereotypes
Generalization about Mexicans with green cards not seeking naturalization.
Keywords matched
naturalized green card immigration immigrants green cards migrants naturalization immigrate refugees naturalize

Classification

Target group
Sentiment
Mixed
Stereotyping
⚠️ Yes
Confidence
95%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Economic contributor Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
ALAN SIMPSON
Party
R
Chamber
S
State
WY
Gender
M
Date
1983-05-17
Speech ID
980042956
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →