Session #98 · 1983–85

Speech #980042954

Mr. President. as the bill now stands. those illegal aliens granted legal status will become eligible for entitlement benefits in 3 to 5 yearssome of them within 3 years. some of them within 5 years. The purpose of my amendment is to preclude eligibility for entitlement benefits until such aliens attain naturalized U.S. citizenship. I make a distinction between legal aliens. that is. thove who have come to the country by awaiting their time in line. and those illegal aliens who in effect are granted amnesty. With respect to the former. my bill has no effect. That is. legal aliens who come into the country under the quota system are not affected in any way by my amendment. Rather. it is focused on illegal aliens. those who have come into this country illegally and who under this bill are being granted amnesty. that is. permanent resident status or temporary resident status. Mr. President. we do not know how many illegal aliens there are in this country. Estimates range from 3 million to 12 million. Since we do not know how many illegal aliens there are who will be granted amnesty by this bill and who will eventually become eligible for entitlement benefits. we have no way of knowing how much it will cost the taxpayers of this country to support them under various entitlement programs. Nevertheless. the Department of Health and Human Services. presumably based on the administration estimate of 61/4 million illegal aliens. has estimated that the cost of entitlement programs for illegal aliens will rise from $165 million in 1984 to over $1 billion per year in 1990obviously. very great sums. Are those persons who broke the law. who entered the country contrary to the law due entitlement benefits? I think not. Should the taxpayers of the United States be expected to provide entitlement benefits to those who are in this country contrary to the law? I think not. If such illegal aliens eventually become naturalized citizens. then under my amendment they would be due entitlement benefits. provided they meet certain criteria. The effect of the amendment is very simple. It precludes entitlement benefits to illegal aliens granted amnesty under this bill until they attain naturalized U.S. citizenship. Mr. President.
Keywords matched
quota system naturalized illegal aliens

Classification

Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Economic threat Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
GORDON HUMPHREY
Party
R
Chamber
S
State
NH
Gender
M
Date
1983-05-17
Speech ID
980042954
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →