Mr. Speaker. this conference committee on social security deleted what I believe to be a very unfortunate provision added in the other body. That provision would have prohibited an individual who is an undocumented alien from receiving any social security benefits if that person paid into the social security system while in undocumented status. Such a provision is unfortunate because it amounts to scapegoating those undocumented aliens who. although they are in this country technically illegally. in fact have been contributors to our economy and our society. We are talking about individuals who have worked in this country. who answered the job lure which brought them from their home countries. They are here because of our failure to control our borders. We are penalizing then when they have been doing what any sensible person would do. come to this country and answer the many "help wanted" signs we have posted for them. The Senate amendment made absolutely no allowance for any equities built up through long residence and comaendable contribution to our society. Conceivably. an undocumented alien could become a successful businessman in the United States. have a number of Americanborn children. and hence. American citizen children. He could be a respected pillar of society. He could. in all probability. have forgotten that he was undocumented. And. he would. after 30 to 40 years of paying taxes in the United States. be penalized upon his retirement. I believe this is appalling. The proper way to deal with the undocumented alien population is to pass H.R. 1510. the Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1983. sponsored by my good friend and chairman of the Immigration Subcommittee. Congressman RON MAZZOLI. That bill. by imposing penalties on empolyers who knowingly hire undocumented aliens. would end the job lure which brings them to this country. It does not do our Nation proud to have no effective control of our borders. and then penalize those who have come and work for us. This Senate amendment is perhaps the first sign of something that has worried me and many of those who have worked on the immigration refrom bill. If we do not achieve a rational and balanced immigration policy. such as that found in H.R. 1510. we will be inclined to take dramatic. and I believe improper steps directed against undocumented aliens. I hope that I am wrong and this amendment is an isolated incident. But. whether it is or not. I do not want to take any chances. I want to see the Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1983 signed into law.*
Keywords matched
undocumented Immigration immigration