Japan. The Netherlands and Nicaragua may be particularly concerned since they may consider that their 27yearold FCN treaty with the United States protects them from such non"national treatment" of their citizens. Third. an amendment by the Junior Senator from Oklahoma reduces or eliminates payments to legal residents and U.S. citizens who are dependents of affected noncitizens. It could also lead to a discriminatory review of the eligibility of millions of U.S. citizens and lawabiding noncitizens who are suspected of being illegal immigrants to the United States. Most of the people who would have their benefits eliminated next January are already aged. disabled or survivor beneficiaries living in the United States. All of them have worked in the United States. paid social security taxes and met the same social security eligibility requirements that are the prerequisites for receipt of any social security benefit. In the Senate debate. the amendments sponsor stated that this provision would not apply to illegal aliens who may be given legal status through a general amnesty provision in future immigration legislation. However. the amendments legislative language specifically requires a noncitizen toi prove he/she legally entered the United States with permission to work. Therefore. under the legislative provisions. current legal status might not be enough to permit full payments. Inclusion of these provisions is unfortunate because: First. they will harm our relationships with substantial numbers of our allies while achieving trivial savings for social security. second. they may lead to similar responses by other countries toward U.S. citizens. and third. they could be detrimental to our efforts to expand U.S. exports.
Keywords matched
illegal immigrants noncitizen noncitizens immigration illegal aliens