More important. since labor will not settle for an unalterable secondclass citizenship. the true cost of labor includes whatever it takes to bring the laborer and his children ultimately into a condition of full membership in the community. Many of these costs are externalized as far as the employer is concerned: schools. health services. welfare Dayments. It takes a tremendous community investmentover one or more generationsto bring the immigrant and his family fully into the community. Employers pay few of these external costs. Most are paid by the citizens at large. It takes a lot of money to turn new immigrants into fully acculturated citizens. The nominal low cost of immigrant labor is an illusion. but without community actionthe passage and enforcement of lawsindividual business enterprisers will continue to benefit from a dishonest accounting system. We must note that the interests of the community. though great. are diffuse. I know that I lose every time one more immigrant comes across the border. To acculturate fully one more immigrant and his family may cost my nation a hundred thousand dollars. But that cost (whatever its true magnitude) is divided among some eighty million taxpayers: my proportionate share is less than a penny. The cost of a million immigrants is. of course. much moreover a thousand dollars per taxpayer. But this cost is invisibly spread over several decades. It is only by intellectualizing the matter that we see that Immigrants do not come cheap. Our direct. intuitive appreciation of this really is almost nil. It takes imagination to see the truth. The ones who suffer most from "cheap" immigrant labor are the residents who get the worst deal in other respects: unskilled laborers. blacks. and teenagers not in school. This is a large constituency. but not an organized one. What about wellorganized. powerful labor unions? They. if any people. should be the constitutency working for restrictions on immigration. In fact. they are now taking only the first. hesitant steps. Why the apparent reluctance to pursue what is clearly in their own interest? There is no overall answer. but we can see a few partial answers. The United Farm Workers who. more than any other union. feel the pressure of immigrant labor. are ambivalent. The situation of their leader. Cesar Chavez. stands as a symbol for all: a nativeborn U.S. citizen. he has deep roots in Mexico. The typical U.F.W. member sees the need for stopping immigration. but he wants to delay any action until his cousins get in. Of course. the cousins. too. have cousins. and so on ad infinitum. A century ago unemployed laborers who saw jobs being given to fresh immigrants reacted violently against the newcomers. Employers who benefited from cheap labor controlled the police force. which they used to repress labors struggles to protect itself. Where did the "verbals." the journalists. stand in this fray? Most of them sided with the employers. Immigrants do not threaten to take jobs away from native "verbals." because new immigrants. particularly poor immigrants. are inept with words. It takes imagination for a "verbal" to perceive the threat an immigrant poses to native manual workers. Most journalists fail to pass this test. contenting themselves with using their verbal skills to castigate native manual workers who seek to protect their livelihood: the words "bigotry." "chauvinism." and "prejudice" fill the air. Selfrighteousness comes easy to the man whose rice bowl is not threatened.
Keywords matched
immigrant immigration immigrants Immigrants