Session #95 · 1977–79

Speech #950394225

H. Freeman. 1977). a collection of articles exemplifying. developing. and criticizing the theory of the commons. The application of the theory to the immigration problem was first pointed out in my article. "Living on a Lifeboat." in BioScience. 24:561568. 1974. which is also reprinted in Managing the Commons. A more thorough development of the ethical implications. of the theory can be found in my book The Linuss of Altruism. (Bloomington: Indiana University Press. 1977). inishes in the process of sharing. Uncontrolled immigration will not come to a halt until the wealth of the receiving country is reduced to the level of the nation supplying the immigrants. i.e.. until the poor wouldbe immigrants perceive no more possibility of satisfying their needs by migrating. "Share the weath" is an illusory goal: only poverty can be shared. If immigration were a onetime affair the danger of sharing might be safely ignored. But unrestrained population growth. continued indefinitely into the future. constitutes a threat without limit. Mexico is the largest source of immigrants into the United States at the moment. contributing (it is believed) about twothirds of the inflow. (Other sources may become more important in the future. What is said here about Mexican immigration may soon be applicable. mutatis mutandis. to imigration from other countries.) For the present. let us focus on the MexicanU.S. population dynamics. As of 1977. the official population of Mexico was sixtythree million. and its rate of national increase was 3.7 per cent. This means that the yearly increase (neglecting emigration) was 2.331.000 people. The U.S. population was 224 million. and the rate of increase not counting immigration was 0.5 per cent. this yields a yearly increase of 1.120.000. In other words. Mexico. with only twentyeight per cent as great a population. produced 108 per cent more people in absolute numbers. Because population grows by compound interest. the disparity in population growth. in the absence of fundamental changes. will increase year by year. The potential for Mexican immigration (not to mention immigration from other sources) to overwhelm the resident U.S. population in the course of time is obvious. Tragically. impoverishing the United States cannot improve the situation in Mexico. as long as Mexican fertility remains undiminished. In a finite worldand that Is the only world we knowany rate of population Increase greater than a fiat zero is. ultimately. too high a rate. Population control is the greatest problem for all nations. and it is not solved by emigrationwhich merely encourages a nations leaders to evade the hard issue of population control in their own territory. By resorting to emigration an overpopulated country can export its problems to any country that is foolish enough to permit uncontrolled immigrationwith no longterm gain to either nation. The foundation on which any ethical analysis of immigration must be erected is this: no policy. however amiable in intent. that produces mutual ruin in the long run can be defended on ethical grounds. Massive immigration damages the receiving nation even in the near term. Every new baby or new immigrant imnoses acculturation costsboth monetary and otheron the nurturant nation. Unless the utter disruption of the native cultureH is regarded as a matter of no moment. the public costs of acculturating immigrants and the children of immigrants is much greater than the public costs of acculturating the children of longtime residents. The present U.S. population of 224 million people with a fertility of fourteen per thousand produces 3.136.000 children in a year. If the years inflow of immigrants (legal and illegal) is two million. this means that the load of immigrants to be acculturated is sixtyfour per cent as great as the acculturation load of new babies. That estimate is based on counting only bodies. Actually. many of the new babies are born into immigrant homes and will impose an even heavier acculturation cost on the publicand next year there will be a new wave of fertile immigrants. The total costs of acculturation imposed by immigrants is difficult to determine. but with rising immigration and falling native fertility these costs must be rising. To survive as a people every nation must produce the next generation. but doing so largely by immigration is not the most economic way. whether one understands economics in a broad sense or a narrow sense. Who would propose. as a matter of policy. that immigration be the preferred way for producing the next generation? From the point of view of welfare economics. illuminated by human ecological insights. the case against unrestricted Immigration in a crowded world is overwhelming. Common folk. outside idealistic and bemused academia. understand this perfectly well. and always have. Unfortunately those who speak in the American media are more influenced by academia than by the common folk. "Intellectuals"-more accurately described as "verbals"-are reluctant to reexamine old cliches. "A nation of immigrants." "the open door policy." "my brothers keeper." "fortress America." "isolationism." "for whom the bell tolls": these are only a few of the verbal blockages that are being imposed against independent thought. In addition to the semantic problem there Is the substantive problem of finding an effective political constituency for restrictive immigration policies. It is easy to verify that many people. as individuals. and many groups. as groups. stand to benefit by unrestricted immigration in the short run. even though. as American citizens. they (and their progeny) will lose in the long run. In a moment of cynicism John Maynard Keynes once said. "In the long run we are all dead". unfortunately this bon mot admirably excuses shallow scholars from taking the long view. Unfortunately also. however much economists may discount the future. It is absolutely certain that it eventually gets to us. Who. in fact. benefits by uncontrolled immigration? If it is illegal. the illegals dare not complain about being paid less than the legal minimum wage. so many employers benefit. Even if the wage offered is legal it may be too low to tempt resident Americans accustomed to the easy life. though it may be welcomed by ambitious immigrants fleeing even lower wages (or none at all) back home. Moreover. immigrants as a group are evidently willing to work harder than resident Americans. even at the same wage. immigrants may be more of a bargain for the employer than longtime citizens. Service jobs in restaurants and hotels have long been held by the latest wave of immigrants. employers maintain they could not stay In business if they had to depend on native labor. In a sense they may be right. If we were honest with ourselves we vould see that immigration reveals that we are hypocritical in our praise of the economic dogma of "the market." In a true market economy the price of a product should reflect all the costs. including labor. that go into it. If the price is high. economic demand will be less. The true cost may be greater than anyone is willing to pay. in which case the product "prices itself out of the market." (How long has it been since you bought a jar of pheasants tongues in the supermarket?) Growers of California lettuce have long maintained they could stay in business only if they had available lowpriced "stoop laborillegal immigrants or "green card" holders (temporary guest workers). But there are other possibilities: the price of the product could be raised to reflect higher labor costs. in that case New Yorkers would either eat higherpriced lettuce or do without. In the latter event. lettuce farms could be devoted to growing something else.
Keywords matched
immigrant Immigration emigration green card immigration immigrants immigrationwith emigrationwhich open door policy

Classification

Target group
Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Economic threat Cultural threat

Speaker & context

Speaker
CLAIR BURGENER
Party
R
Chamber
H
State
CA
Gender
M
Date
—
Speech ID
950394225
Paragraph
#8
← Prev Next →