Session #115 · 2017–19

Speech #CREC-2018-02-14-pt1-PgS930-5_t85

There is no curb on an individual's ability to redress that if they were wrongfully detained. It simply transfers the liability from the municipality to the origination of the detainer request, which is the Department of Homeland Security. So that is the first part: solve the legal liability problem which has some municipalities across America--certainly in my State of Pennsylvania--choosing to be sanctuary cities, even though they would rather not be. Now, having addressed that, if our legislation is adopted, and we have thereby solved this legal liability problem, if a community nevertheless decides it is going to endanger all the rest of us by conferring this special protection on somebody just because they came here illegally--despite the fact that they may well be a dangerous criminal--in that case, under my amendment, that community will be deemed a sanctuary city, and under my amendment several types of Federal funding would be withheld from it. Specifically, we would withhold from the sanctuary cities community development block grants and certain grants from the Economic Development Administration. I think this is eminently reasonable. Sanctuary cities impose costs on all of us. They raise the cost to the Federal Government of enforcing immigration law, but by far outweighing that is the cost to the American people of more crime and the unbelievable, staggering cost to families like Jim Steinle and his family, who lost their daughter. I think it is extremely reasonable to have as a policy that if a community chooses to impose those costs on the rest of us, the Federal Government will not be subsidizing it. Let me debunk some of the misinformation that is occasionally disseminated about my amendment. One is that it is somehow anti- immigrant. This is not anti-immigrant at all; this is pro-immigrant. The fact is, the vast, overwhelming majority of immigrants in America, legal and illegal, would never commit these terrible crimes; there is no question about that. It is also obviously the case that any very large number of people will include some criminals among them. There are roughly 11 million people who are here illegally--11 million illegal immigrants in the United States. Some of them are certainly violent criminals. It makes no sense to insulate those violent criminals, however few they may be, from capture by law enforcement. It would be absurd to allege that this is somehow anti- immigrant when quite likely some of their victims will be other immigrants. Immigrants want to live in safe communities too. I am positive of that. They don't want dangerous criminals to be able to walk the streets just because they came here illegally. The second point I want to stress is that this amendment does not discourage or punish illegal immigrants for coming forward to report a crime. This is important because folks who want to keep sanctuary cities sometimes charge that if my legislation were passed, victims and witnesses to crimes, if they are here illegally, wouldn't come forward. That is not so. My amendment in this underlying law explicitly states that a locality will not be labeled a sanctuary jurisdiction for this purpose, and therefore will not lose any Federal funds, if it has a policy stating that if a person comes forward as a victim or a witness to a crime, local law enforcement will not share information with DHS.
Identified stereotypes
Implies that a significant portion of undocumented immigrants are violent criminals.
Keywords matched
immigration illegal immigrants sanctuary city Immigrants immigrants sanctuary cities anti-immigrant Sanctuary cities sanctuary cities immigrant

Classification

Sentiment
Mixed
Stereotyping
⚠️ Yes
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Security threat Criminal Legal / procedural Economic threat

Speaker & context

Speaker
PATRICK TOOMEY
Party
R
Chamber
S
State
PA
Gender
—
Date
2018-02-14
Speech ID
CREC-2018-02-14-pt1-PgS930-5_t85
Paragraph
#6
← Prev Next →