Session #115 · 2017–19

Speech #CREC-2018-02-14-pt1-PgS930-5_t85

Instead, they released this man back onto the streets from which, 3 months later, he murdered young Kate Steinle. Why would the police of San Francisco do a thing like that? Why in the world would they refuse to provide this minimal cooperation with immigration authorities with respect to a dangerous individual? The reason is because San Francisco is a sanctuary city. That means it has as its explicit legal policy a prohibition that forbids their police from cooperating with Federal immigration officials, even if the police want to. It extends to other law enforcement, like sheriffs and deputy sheriffs. This is the case even when local law enforcement authorities believe the person is dangerous, and the local law enforcement folks wish to cooperate with the Federal authorities because they know this person is a threat to the security of their community, but local politicians override the police and decide this will be a sanctuary city. Such is the case with San Francisco, and so the San Francisco Police had no choice. They were required by local laws to release this man onto the streets. One of the many ironies about sanctuary cities is if Federal officials had called the San Francisco Police about any number of other crimes--robbery, car theft, violating a trademark, counterfeiting--any number of other Federal crimes, then the San Francisco Police would have been allowed to cooperate. They would have been happy to cooperate. They would have been able to cooperate, but because the crime was committed by an illegal immigrant, the police's hands were tied. The police were forced to release Kate Steinle's killer. It is just unbelievable to me that we have communities across the country that wish to provide this special privilege--this special protection--for even dangerous criminals because they are here illegally. It is unbelievable, but that is the case. Sadly, the Steinles are not alone. They are not the only family who has been affected this way because, of course, San Francisco is not our Nation's only sanctuary city. Philadelphia--the fifth largest city in America, the largest city in my home State--has an extreme sanctuary city policy, and it has had appalling consequences already. Maybe the most heartbreaking of these is the case of Ramon Aguirre- Ochoa. Ochoa was a Honduran national in the United States illegally. He was deported in 2009, but he illegally reentered the United States, which is itself a felony. He found his way to Philadelphia, and in 2015 the Philadelphia Police arrested him on charges of aggravated assault and various other crimes. When the background check went through, the Department of Homeland Security saw that the Philadelphia Police had this guy. They knew who this guy was. They knew he was here illegally, they knew he had been deported, and they believed him to be the dangerous criminal that he was. So they asked the Philadelphia Police: Could you hold this guy for 24, 48 hours, until we can get an agent there to take him into custody and begin deportation proceedings? We know he is a bad guy. We want him out of the country.
Identified stereotypes
Suggesting that sanctuary cities provide special protection for dangerous criminals because they are here illegally.
Keywords matched
immigration sanctuary city sanctuary city illegal immigrant deported sanctuary cities deportation

Classification

Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
⚠️ Yes
Confidence
95%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Security threat Criminal

Speaker & context

Speaker
PATRICK TOOMEY
Party
R
Chamber
S
State
PA
Gender
—
Date
2018-02-14
Speech ID
CREC-2018-02-14-pt1-PgS930-5_t85
Paragraph
#3
← Prev Next →