I thank them
all. The basic facts of this debate are clear. The American people
overwhelmingly support finding a solution for Dreamers that protects
them from deportation and provides a pathway to citizenship for those
who work hard and play by the rules. I believe that a bipartisan
majority of my colleagues want the same thing. The question before us
is whether the partisanship and raw feelings surrounding this debate
will prevent a solution to this crisis from becoming law. So I urge my
colleagues: Let us forge the bipartisan agreement that the American
people want and the Dreamers deserve. Let us end this crisis. Then,
after this bipartisan show of good faith, let us again take up the kind
of comprehensive immigration reform that many of us in this body have
already voted to pass so we can fix our broken immigration system once
and for all. I do not believe, however, that solving the DACA crisis, which
President Trump in a sense created, should come at the cost of
radically restructuring legal immigration. According to the
conservative Cato Institute, President Trump's immigration proposals in
exchange for resolving the DACA crisis would result in an approximate
44-percent reduction in legal immigration. This would be the largest
cut to immigration in nearly a century. In addition to the profound
effects such a cut would have on American families, culture, and
opportunities, it would also level a massive blow to the American labor
force and economic growth. According to the Cato Institute and the independent research firm
Macroeconomic Advisers, slashing legal immigration by about half could
initially cut our projected economic growth rate by 12.5 percent in the
next year or two. That would be a significant blow to our economy, and
it could lead to further reduced economic growth projections down the
line due to the reduction in the size of the American workforce. And,
just as our Nation faces a skyrocketing deficit due to the impact of
policies like the Republican tax plan, the National Academy of Sciences
estimates that immigrants, on average, contribute over $92,000 more
than they receive in government benefits over the course of their
lives, and losing these American workers would only further shrink
revenue that could help balance the budget. If Congress decides to take on immigration reform of this magnitude,
it must be in the context of bipartisan, comprehensive immigration
reform, and not in the context of resolving this crisis that has been
prompted by President Trump. Nor should this discussion suggest that a desire to do the right
thing by Dreamers somehow indicates a lack of appreciation for the
importance of securing our borders. I believe my colleagues on both
sides of the aisle agree that border security is of critical importance
to our Nation. I have voted to increase the vetting of visa applicants,
to heighten security on international travel, and to increase support
for homeland security and border control by billions of dollars. In
Fiscal Year 2000, there were 8,619 Border Patrol agents on the
southwest border. Today, there are currently just shy of 20,000. The
Obama administration alone added more than 3,000 Border Patrol agents
on our southern Border, doubled the amount of fencing, and added
technological systems, including aerial and ground surveillance
systems. Unlawful immigration began lessening under President Obama,
and today, fewer people are entering the country illegally across the
U.S.-Mexico border than in the past 50 years. I believe in a strong
border that continues to adapt the best technologies and tactics to
keep our Nation safe. What I do not believe in, however, is symbolic
action, like the construction of a wall that would drain taxpayer
dollars without making Americans any safer. There is a reason that Americans on both sides of the political
divide have spoken out against deporting Dreamers. A great many of
these young people are outstanding and accomplished, and our
communities would feel the loss of all that they contribute. It is true
that they were brought here as children outside the appropriate
processes, but this was through no fault of their own. As they have
grown up here, they have pursued higher education, started American
families, worked hard and paid taxes, and stayed out of trouble with
the law. They have passed background checks, been fingerprinted, paid
hundreds of dollars in fees, and submitted detailed records to
immigration enforcement officials whose job it is to prevent fraud and
spot any criminals in the system. Indeed, DACA status is not blanket
amnesty or an entitlement, but is something that must be earned and
kept up. Hundreds of DACA recipients served in the U.S. Armed Forces, like
Zion Dirgantara, whose mother brought him and his brother from
Indonesia to Philadelphia when they were young, and who did not know
about his undocumented status until he applied for a driver's license. Last fall, Zion told the Washington Post that he was deeply affected
when, at age 12, he watched the crash of United Flight 93 in his new
home State of Pennsylvania on September 11, 2001, but he could not join
the Army out of high school because of his undocumented status. Because
of DACA, he was able to enlist in the Army, but both his status and his
ability to continue serving his country hang in the balance during this
debate. Many of my colleagues have spoken movingly and eloquently about the
Dreamers who have come forward to tell their stories. I associate
myself with their remarks, and challenge my colleagues who have not met
these young people in person to listen to their stories and
perspectives. Over the last few months, I, and my staff, have had the
opportunity to meet several very impressive Dreamers living in Rhode
Island who have illustrated what the loss of DACA means to them and
their families. I met one young woman studying at Brown University who
needs DACA to ensure that she can stay here to attend medical school
and help fill the shortage of doctors in America. Another young man I
met told me that DACA, for him, means being able to drive to school and
work every day to save up for advanced education. These young people want to live productive lives and, indeed,
according to the Center for American Progress, letting DACA expire
completely would
cost our Nation's economy over $460 billion over the next decade,
including an annual loss to Rhode Island's economy of an estimated $60
million. Finding a solution for these people is not just the right
thing to do, but it also makes smart economic sense, and I believe that
is part of the reason why the American people are largely in agreement
on helping Dreamers. I also wish to note that this same moral and economic sense applies
to the need to provide deportation relief and legal status for
qualified recipients of Temporary Protected Status, or TPS, and
Deferred Enforced Departure. These individuals came to America from
devastated parts of the world seeking safety and a fresh start, and
they have become integral members of our community and our economy. Like DACA recipients, they have passed rigorous and periodic background
checks, paid hundreds of dollars in fees, and demonstrated that they
are not risks to public safety or national security. The average TPS
beneficiary has been in America for 19 years and many have been here
even longer. About 70 percent to 80 percent are employed, and they are
collectively parents to nearly 275,000 American citizen children. Since 1999, I have been fighting for a pathway to citizenship for
Liberians who came to States like Rhode Island to escape two bloody
civil wars and the Ebola virus outbreak. Some of these Liberian
refugees have been fixtures of our community for nearly 30 years but,
like DACA recipients, they could face deportation in a number of weeks
because of the expiration of TPS and DED protections. Congress can and
should include these populations in the solutions we discuss here this
week. Mr. President, I, along with many of my colleagues, have taken the
tough votes to strengthen our border and ensure immigrants play by the
rules. I have voted for the DREAM Act and for comprehensive immigration
reform that passed in this body. I know that we can address this crisis
if we choose to, but I also know that the only true path forward is
real bipartisan compromise, not posturing or legislative gamesmanship. I urge my colleagues to support compromise legislation to address the
specific crisis before us and, when we have done that, to begin earnest
discussions on bipartisan and comprehensive immigration reform. I yield the floor. I suggest the absence of a quorum.
Keywords matched
immigration refugees visa undocumented Border Patrol immigrants DACA deporting Temporary Protected Status border control TPS border security deportation