Session #115 · 2017–19

Speech #CREC-2018-02-12-pt1-PgS856-3_t19

This bill is the one bill that can become a law because it is the one bill that translates the President's framework into actual legislation. It provides legal status and ultimately citizenship for people who were brought here through no fault of their own as minors, before the age of accountability. It provides more money and legal authorities to secure our southern border and to help our brave immigration agents. It eliminates the useless diversity visa lottery and reallocates those green cards for more productive and worthwhile purposes, and it puts an end to the practice of extended-family chain migration, allowing immigrants to bring not just his or her spouse and minor children but parents, siblings, and, ultimately, grandparents, aunts, uncles, cousins, and on down their extended family tree. That doesn't solve every problem under the sun we have with immigration. It doesn't, for instance, include mandatory nationwide E- Verify, which I would support. It doesn't resolve the many problems we have with numerous temporary guest worker visas. But it is consistent with the President's framework, and it solves the problem in front of us of young people who were brought here through no fault of their own, but also it has the side effect of giving those people legal status. I know there are a lot of half measures floating around the Senate right now, saying that we should give legal status to these 1.8 million people in return for a small pittance at the southern border, but that simply will not do. It is not responsible because if we give those people legal status, we will have two negative side effects. First, we will create more incentives--perverse incentives--to encourage illegal immigration with minor children to this country. That is dangerous. It is immoral, not to mention unwise from our national interests. Second, if we give legal status to these 1.8 million people, we will create a whole new pool of legal permanent residents and, ultimately, citizens who can naturalize their extended family, including their parents--the very people who created the problem to begin with-- undermining the rationale for the program to begin with. Remember, that rationale was that children ought not pay for the sins of their parents. But, surely, parents can pay for their own sins. If we do those things--provide legal status for the 1.8 million people who find themselves in this situation through no fault of their own, but control those negative side effects by securing our border, and ending the practice of extended-family chain migration--we will have a bill that can become a law. At the same time, we will also grandfather in every person who is currently in the backlog waiting to come to this country, who has applied to get a green card because they have a parent or child or sibling in this country. Some of them have been waiting up to 20 years. So no one will be cut out of that waiting line. Furthermore, we will continue to allow American citizens to get a renewable, nonworker visa for their elderly parents who live overseas. So if you immigrated to this country and still have parents back in the home country who need your care, who need to live at home with you or maybe live down the street in a nursing home, this law will allow you to have a visa to bring them here. That is a generous, humane solution, but it also is one that handles the problem responsibly and starts to build the kind of immigration system that this country needs--a system that focuses on the skills that our economy needs, not one that is just based on family ties or country of origin. For that reason, it is immensely popular. A recent poll showed that 65 percent of Americans support this proposal. Two out of every three Americans support it, and they should, since, after all, every part of this proposal is popular. Most of us have seen polls that suggest that fewer than 20 percent of Americans want to see these people return to their country, which in many cases they don't remember. At the same time, 72 percent want to end the practice of extended-family chain migration, and securing our southern border is equally as popular. Oftentimes in Congress, we have to make a tough choice between something that is popular and necessary and something that is unpopular, but in this legislation, we are simply asking our colleagues to do the right thing--to take the responsible step--which happens to be popular with the American people as well. It should be popular because it is both generous and humane on the one hand but responsible on the other hand. It is the only approach that will begin to change our immigration system from one that treats people based on where they come from and to whom they are related to a system that treats them for who they are. There is nothing that could be more American than that. I urge my colleagues to recognize that this is the one bill that the House of Representatives can pass, can earn the President's signature, and can become a law.
Keywords matched
immigration visa immigrants illegal immigration naturalize immigrated chain migration green card green cards visas

Classification

Target group
Sentiment
Mixed
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Legal / procedural Economic contributor Family values

Speaker & context

Speaker
TOM COTTON
Party
R
Chamber
S
State
AR
Gender
—
Date
2018-02-12
Speech ID
CREC-2018-02-12-pt1-PgS856-3_t19
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →