Session #115 · 2017–19

Speech #CREC-2018-02-06-pt1-PgS619-2_t0

I wanted him to hear about it, to know the details, and I hoped that it would solve the problem and challenge that we faced. It was a real compromise. The day after we finalized that agreement, after the House meeting, we addressed all of the priorities that the President had laid before us, including protection for the Dreamers and a significant, multibillion-dollar downpayment on our border security. The President said he looked forward to Senator Graham's briefing him on that plan and would be back in touch with me. Then I received word, within minutes, that the President wanted me to join Senator Graham in going to the White House. Two hours later, Senator Lindsey Graham and I were at the White House, hoping that the President might embrace our bipartisan plan, but we were surprised and disappointed when we entered the Oval Office. In a matter of an hour and a half, five of the congressional hard-liners on immigration had been invited in to shoot down our plan. The President's views, in a matter of less than 2 hours, had changed radically. During our meeting, the President demanded $20 billion to build a wall on our southern border. He kept saying over and over: Give me $20 billion. I will build this wall in 1 year. The President reacted negatively to the agreement that we had reached in terms of protecting immigrants from Haiti from deportation and ensuring that immigrants from Africa would be permitted to come to our country. What I heard at that meeting had nothing to do with security and American jobs. It was a sad commentary by the President on his vision of immigration. Then, 2 weeks ago, Senator Schumer, our Democratic leader, made another good-faith attempt to work with the White House. He made a generous offer to President Trump to fund the border wall, but after a promising meeting, within 2 hours, the President called and withdrew any offer. That was the third time Senate Democrats had offered to fund President Trump's wall in exchange for the Dream Act. In other words, we have been willing to support a broadly unpopular and partisan proposal--the wall--in exchange for a broadly popular and bipartisan proposal--the Dream Act. The President will not take ``yes'' for an answer. It is no wonder that Senator Schumer has said that trying to reach an immigration agreement with the President is ``like trying to negotiate with Jell-O.'' Two weeks ago, the White House released a 1-page ``Framework on Immigration Reform & Border Security.'' The White House claims this is a compromise because it includes a path to citizenship for some Dreamers. I might add that it is an issue that is supported by the overwhelming majority of American people. The plan would put the administration's entire hard-line immigration agenda on the backs of these young people. For example, the White House wants to dramatically reduce legal immigration by prohibiting American citizens from sponsoring their parents, siblings, and adult or married children as immigrants. We are talking about, literally, millions of relatives of American citizens who have done the right thing, followed our immigration laws, and have been waiting patiently in line for as long as 20 years to come to the United States. Listen to what the Cato Institute says about the White House proposal: [I]n the most likely scenario, the new plan would cut the number of legal immigrants by up to 44 percent or half a million immigrants annually--the largest policy-driven legal immigration cut since the 1920s. Compared to current law, it would exclude--[the President's proposal]--nearly 22 million people from the opportunity to immigrate legally to the United States over the next [50 years]. This proposal would gut the 1965 Immigration and Nationality Act, which established our current immigration system, with its focus on reuniting families. When you think about the bedrock principles of America--faith, family, love of country--why would we assault this effort to unify and strengthen our families in America with those who are following this process in a legal manner? The 1965 law, which this would change dramatically, replaced the strict national origin quotas of the 1924 immigration law. The 1924 immigration law was written to specifically exclude people whom the Congress and President, in those days, thought should not be part of America's future. They were focusing on people from my part of the world. My family came from the Baltics. They focused on the Baltics and Eastern European countries--to restrict their immigration to this country. Luckily for me, my family got over before the 1924 law. They also wanted to exclude Italians in their belief that we had had enough from that country, and they wanted to exclude Jews. That is what that 1924 National Security Act was about. When President Lyndon Johnson signed the 1965 law, he said: ``It corrects a cruel and enduring wrong. . . . For over four decades the immigration policy of the United States has been twisted and distorted by the harsh injustice of the national origins quota system.'' Listen to what Presidential Calvin Coolidge said when he signed the 1924 law, the last major reduction in legal immigration in America: There are racial considerations too grave to be brushed aside. Biological laws tell us that certain people will not mix or blend. The Nordics propagate themselves successfully. With other races, the outcome shows deterioration on both sides. I cannot understand why Attorney General Sessions, at one point, praised that 1924 law and said it was ``good for America.'' The President's immigration framework would also fast-track the deportations of women and children who come to our border in their fleeing gang and sexual violence. Since our tragic failure during World War II to aid Jewish refugees who fled the Holocaust, the United States has led the world, since then, in providing a safe haven to people who flee war, terrorism, and persecution. Now we are in the midst of the worst refugee crisis on record, with 65 million people worldwide being forcibly displaced, including child refugees from Central America, the Northern Triangle, who are fleeing horrific violence. Consider the opinion of General John Kelly back in 2015, the current White House Chief of Staff, when he headed the U.S. Southern Command.
Keywords matched
immigration refugees Border Security immigrants deportations border wall Immigration immigrate national origin quota refugee border security national origins quota deportation

Classification

Target group
Also mentioned
immigrants from Haiti immigrants from Africa
Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
RICHARD DURBIN
Party
D
Chamber
S
State
IL
Gender
—
Date
2018-02-06
Speech ID
CREC-2018-02-06-pt1-PgS619-2_t0
Paragraph
#5
← Prev Next →