Speaker, I include in the Record a letter signed by
a number of civil rights groups, education groups, environmental
groups, and women's groups in opposition to this minibus. July 25, 2017. Re Oppose H.R. 3219 Security Minibus--Vote No on Border wall. House of Representatives,
Washington, DC. Dear Representative: On behalf of our coalition of almost
90 environmental, faith, immigration, and civil rights
organizations, we are writing to strongly urge you to oppose
funding for the continued construction of a border wall along
the U.S.-Mexico border. The construction of a border wall
serves as a symbol of hostility towards immigrants, and
undermines the civil rights of communities living along our
southern border. It also imposes environmental costs and
natural disaster threats on border communities, especially
indigenous communities, harms native wildlife and wastes tens
of billions in taxpayer dollars. As the House moves to consider the Fiscal Year 2018
Security Minibus, H.R. 3219, we are profoundly concerned
about the inclusion of $1.6 billion slated for border wall. In addition to spending billions of taxpayer dollars, adding
funding for the border wall in this legislative package
undermines a fair and transparent legislative process. Instead of allowing legislators and the public to fully
consider the impacts of funding wall construction, the
Majority is using rushed and underhanded legislative
maneuvers to circumvent the vast and legitimate opposition
that exists for this measure, even within their own party. Including border wall funding in a Security Minibus is
based on the false premise that our borders are somehow
violent and insecure. This false premise has been used to
justify and advance anti-immigrant, anti-border, pro-
criminalization, and anti-environment legislation that has
negative economic and civil rights impacts on border
communities. The fact is that communities along the border
are some of the safest in the country. According to the FBI's
Uniformed Crime Reports, cities on the border are safer than
cities away from the border. Places like El Paso, Texas have
long topped the lists of safest cities for their low crime
and violence. Additionally, according to the American
Immigration Council, communities with more immigrants are
likely to be safer than places with fewer immigrants. Border walls are an ineffective tool in curbing
undocumented migration between the United States and nations
south of the border. Rather than deter migration, the current
650-mile barrier along the U.S.-Mexico border has forced
vulnerable migrant populations to pursue more dangerous
routes of travel. The continued construction of a border wall
portrays an attitude of hatred and animosity towards our
neighboring nations. Additionally, construction of this wall
would undermine indigenous border communities, potentially
destroying elements of their history, archeology, and
culture. Border security measures must consider the historic
Tribal lands and families occupying the southern border. Finally, the current proposal in Fiscal Year 2018 Security
Minibus calls for the construction of 60 miles of levee
border wall in the South Texas Rio Grande Valley; 28 miles
would be levee-border wall, with 2.9 miles slated to be built
in the Santa Ana Wildlife Refuge. This Refuge is home to
diverse wildlife species, ecotourism opportunities, and rich
natural beauty. When levee border walls are constructed, they
negatively impact wildlife migration, pose severe flooding
risks, destroy natural habitats, and lead to potential
increased extinction rates. In order to construct existing
border-walls, dozens of laws protecting our environment,
public health, and sacred natural lands were waived. Our
nation's natural habitats, vibrant wildlife, and healthy
ecosystems are an unacceptable sacrifice to make for
ineffective security measures. For all of the above reasons, we strongly urge you to vote
NO on the Fiscal Year 2018 Security Minibus, and oppose
funding for border walls, levees, or additional
infrastructure along the southern border of the United
States. Thank you for your consideration. Sincerely,
Civil Rights
Mi Familia Vota, American-Arab Anti-Discrimination
Committee, Southeast Asia Resource Action Center (SEARAC),
HONOR PAC, UnidosUS (formerly NCLR), American Civil Liberties
Union, Asian Americans Advancing Justice Atlanta, The City
Project, National Council of Asian Pacific Americans (NCAPA),
League of United Latin American Citizens, EPCF.
Keywords matched
immigration undocumented immigrants border wall migrant anti-immigrant Immigration Border wall Border security