Session #113 · 2013–15

Speech #1130108432

There are some and we ought to consider those. but mainly I havent heard anybody come up with another solution to this loophole that is being exploited by these transnational criminal cartels other than the one that Congressman CUELLAR and I have proposed. There have been some who have expressed concerns about the legislation. On the right there are some who have said this bill would make it easier for unaccompanied minors to achieve legal and asylum status. That is wrong. The HUMANE Act. which is what we call this legislation. would not change current law at all with regard to either a claim for asylum or achieving legal status. It would. however. make sure that current law is actually enforced by speeding up court dates and the removal process for unaccompanied children who dont satisfy some of these exceptions. It is also worth reminding the American people that there are a number of fraud prevention measures in our current asylum laws that the HUMANE Act would not change. andand this is importantmore than 70 percent of those seeking asylum in the United States last yearmore than 70 percent of those seeking asylum last year in the United States were ultimately not awarded that status. In other words. this is a rather narrow provision. Some have also argued that the HUMANE Act would somehow expunge the removal orders that were issued to minors who came to the country illegally during the current surge and have already been released to Statebased family members or sponsors. What our bill would actually do is allow the U.S. Government to replace those removal orders with new nonappealable orders that would allow for an expedited repatriation process for the children who were not qualified for asylum status or were not a victim of human trafficking. On the left we have heard the claim that many of these children will not obtain the necessary legal representation they need. Wrong again. The HUMANE Act would not change current law which requires Health and Human Services to ensure to the greatest extent practicable that legal representation is provided for unaccompanied children. I have not heard many of my friends on the other side of the aisle who actually supported the 2008 law unanimously complain about this aspect. in other words. what they are complaining about now in terms of inadequate legal representation they actually voted for in 2008. Some worry that this bill would be a vehicle for comprehensive immigration reform. to which I would ask: Have you witnessed the dysfunction in the U.S. Senate? Do you actually think there is any real chance we will pass comprehensive immigration reform through both Houses of Congress this year? Well. some have said there is also concern there are not enough protections in the bill for children. Yet we have added protections that dont already exist under current law. such as an expedited court hearing before a judge and for those credible claims. stronger safeguards to ensure children are not released in the hands of dangerous criminals or those who would abuse them.
Keywords matched
seeking asylum asylum status immigration asylum laws

Classification

Target group
Sentiment
Neutral
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Legal / procedural Humanitarian

Speaker & context

Speaker
JOHN CORNYN
Party
R
Chamber
S
State
TX
Gender
M
Date
2014-07-21
Speech ID
1130108432
Paragraph
#4
← Prev Next →