Session #113 · 2013–15

Speech #1130107628

That was a sorry part of our history. Usually our history reflects what we see in the Statue of Liberty: a beckoning torch to refuge. But now the refugee crisis has come back again and to our own border. It is a complicated problem. I hope we will stop trying to react to whatever was in the latest news cycle 121/2 seconds ago so we can get to the next sound bite 121/2 seconds from now and resist the urge to let politics shape our response. Critics are arguing that the increase in unaccompanied children arriving at the southwest border is driven by recent changes in our immigration policy. This is a sound bite. The facts. of course. are a lot different. They tell a different and more complicated story. The United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees has found over 50 percent of the children ages 12 to 17 arriving from Guatemala. El Salvador. and Honduras have been forcibly displaced and have claims to international protection because of the violence they have encountered. If changes in immigration policy were the primary factor. we would expect to see an acrosstheboard increase in children arriving from Mexico and Central America. What Guatemala. El Salvador. and Honduras have in common is widespread corruption and weak governments that have failed to implement effective social and economic programs or to protect their most vulnerable citizens from record levels of violence. This reality. more than any change in U.S. policy. is responsible for the massive increase in unaccompanied minors arriving on our southwest border. It is true that many of these children do not have claims to immigration relief and they are going to be returned. For them. the dangers of this trip are not worth it. and we must discourage them from making the arduous journey alone. But others are fleeing murder or being forced into gangs or girls in their early teens are being raped and impregnated.
Keywords matched
Refugees immigration refugee

Classification

Target group
Sentiment
Mixed
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Humanitarian Legal / procedural Victim

Speaker & context

Speaker
PATRICK LEAHY
Party
D
Chamber
S
State
VT
Gender
M
Date
2014-07-16
Speech ID
1130107628
Paragraph
#1
← Prev Next →