Session #113 · 2013–15

Speech #1130105039

It is tough to even know where to begin in responding to these suggestions. but let me try. Let me start from my perspective as a member of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee. It is important first to remember that this is no ordinary issue of border security or of immigration enforcement. This is a humanitarian and a refugee crisis. The tens of thousands of childrenyoung childrenpresenting themselves alone at the border of the United States are not dangerous criminals who threaten our national safety. They are so often children who have traveled thousands of miles from their home countries at enormous risk and expense. and they have come not because our border is wide open. not because it is unsecure. In fact. virtually all of them are being interdicted at the border by our effective border security. The challenge is that these children are being sent on these incredibly long and expensive and dangerous and difficult trips in the first place. Our Republican colleagues have suggested that this is solely caused by our Presidents lawlessness. that somehow either a law that was proposed and passed here in the Senate. a comprehensive immigration reform bill. or the Presidents deferred action program with regard to those who are socalled DREAMers is what is causing this flood of child refugees to this country. But as has been said by other of our colleagues just in the last hour. neither of those two thingsneither the comprehensive immigration bill passed on a bipartisan basis by this Chamber nor the deferred action program of the administrationwould create really any legal opportunity for these child refugees to stay in the United States. Neither of them applies. In order to get access to the benefit and the opportunity to be in the United States under those two provisions. you would have to have been here years ago. The problem is really instability. violence. the tragic collapse of governance and safety in three Central American countries. If the magnet drawing thousands of refugees to this country were the actions or inactions of the President. would not we see a huge surge in refugees from elsewhere in Central America. from Panama or from Belize or from Costa Rica or everyone closer to us from Mexico as well? But we have not. In the last 5 years child migrants from Mexico have stayed relatively flat. while children from the three countries that are the focus of current violenceEl Salvador. Honduras. and Guatemalahave surged out of control. In 2009 child migrants from those three countries made up just 17 percent of all the children trying to come across the American border. This year. threequarters are coming from El Salvador. Honduras. and Guatemala.
Keywords matched
border security immigration migrants refugee refugees

Classification

Target group
Also mentioned
DREAMers
Sentiment
Positive
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Humanitarian Victim

Speaker & context

Speaker
CHRIS COONS
Party
D
Chamber
S
State
DE
Gender
M
Date
2014-07-09
Speech ID
1130105039
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →