Session #113 · 2013–15

Speech #1130104390

Mr. Speaker. sometimes the gap between political hype and reality is so great it demands a rebuttal. The Obama administrations border security hype is a case in point. In February 2013. Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano proclaimed. "the border is secure." Rarely has the gap between hype and reality been so great. Similarly. my Democrat friends and their media allies repeatedly boast about Obamas border security prowess. For example. PBS recently ran a fluff piece boasting: In one term. the Obama administration has deported roughly 80 percent the number of immigrants the George W. Bush administration deported in two. PBS failed to mention that deportations are only half the border enforcement picture. The other half is "catch and returns." whereby Border Patrol catches illegal aliens at the border and promptly escorts them back without the timeconsuming and costly deportation process. So. how does the Obama administration stack up if the full picture is examined? According to Homeland Security data. in 2012. President Obamas catch and return record was way below average. with Border Patrol catching and immediately returning 230.000 illegal aliens. In contrast. in 2008. the Bush administration caught and immediately returned 811.000 illegal aliens. almost four times more than Obama in 2012. Similarly. in 1993. the Clinton administration caught and immediately returned 1.2 million illegal aliens. more than five times than Obama in 2012. Why are Obamas catch and return numbers so bad? A Border Patrol agent told me on Capitol Hill that Obama pushes catch and return illegal aliens into the much slower and far costlier deportation process to inflate Obamas deportation numbers to artificially make Obamas border security record look better. The best indicator of a Presidents border enforcement record is the whole picture: deportations plus catch and returns. In 2012. the Obama administration deported or caught and returned 649.000 illegal aliens. In contrast. in 2008. the Bush administration deported or caught and returned 1.2 million illegal aliens. 80 percent more than President Obama in 2012. Similarly. in 1993. the Clinton administration deported or caught and returned 1.3 million illegal aliens. 98 percent more than the Obama administration in 2012. According to Department of Homeland Security data. and contrary to what my Democrat friends and their media allies would have the public believe. Obamas border security enforcement record is the worst in more than two decades. But there is more. President Obama repeatedly promises amnesty to illegal aliens. As 1986s failed amnesty experiment proves. amnesty begets more illegal immigration. Mr. Speaker. amnesty promises must stop because they make things worse. not better. Further. this administration must stop paying foreigners to illegally cross our borders. This is a nobrainer. America cannot give free food. free clothing. free shelter. free health care. free transportation. and billions of dollars a year in fraudulent tax returns and refunds to illegal aliens and then wonder why we have an illegal alien crisis. These failings contribute to Americas poorest borders and produce millions of illegal aliens competing for American jobs. thereby creating income inequality via wage suppression and lost job opportunities for American citizens. Mr. Speaker. to solve the immigration problem. America must vigorously enforce immigration laws. stop promising illegal aliens amnesty. and stop giving illegal aliens stuff paid for with tax dollars forcefully taken from struggling American families. If America will be smart and do these things. there will be no immigration crisis. there wont be illegal aliens competing with Americans for jobs. and American families can better participate in the American Dream.
Keywords matched
border enforcement border security deportations illegal alien immigration Border Patrol deported illegal aliens deportation illegal immigration immigrants

Classification

Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
90%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Economic threat Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
MO BROOKS
Party
R
Chamber
H
State
AL
Gender
M
Date
2014-07-09
Speech ID
1130104390
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →