Session #113 · 2013–15

Speech #1130102611

It is not a good idea. But he was not simply saying: Do not come unlawfully. In newspapers in Central and South America and on Univisions Web site the letter noted. in part. that the Senate comprehensive immigration bill "provides for an earned path to citizenship. but only for certain people who came into this country on or before December 31. 2011." The Senate bill died in the House and will not become a law. and it was wrong to have done that very thing. That is what the law said. but it wasnt passed. But the very fact that Mr. Johnson is advertising in foreign countries an earned path to citizenship for illegal immigrants undermines his primary responsibility. which is to enforce the law. The most primary responsibility for Mr. Johnson is not to see how many people he can apprehend and actually go through the cost and process of deporting. the primary job is to deter criminal activity to begin with. to send a message and back it up that people cannot come successfully illegally. Dont come. Then you will see a large dropoff instead of this 800percent increase we see today. Human beings are rational actors. and if they believe the United States is granting citizenship to illegal aliens who arrived before 2012. it stands to reason that the U.S. Government will move that date back if more illegal aliens arrive in the years to come. Why wouldnt they think they would be given amnesty too? That is what happened in 1986amnesty was given. There were 3 million people who were given legal status. and the message was heard. Some say that today. we have over 11 million illegal aliens in the country. Even a 2009 internal Department of Homeland Security report on approaches for implementing immigration reform recognizes this fundamental fact. This 2009 report said: Virtually all immigration experts agree that it would be counterproductive to offer an explicit or implied path to permanent resident status (or citizenship) during any legalization program. That would simply encourage the fraud and illegal border crossings that other features of the program seek to discourage. In fact. for that reason and from that perspective. it would be best if the legislation did not even address future permanent resident status or citizenship. That is from an official government report. Contrary to the administrations claims that illegal immigrants are acting on mere rumor and misinformation. it is the sad reality of lax enforcement plus the lack of a clear message that is driving the surge. The reality is if you get into the country today. you are not going to be deported. That is true. A leaked May 30 internal memo written by the top border official. Deputy Chief Ronald Vitiello. said: Currently only 3 percent of apprehensions from countries other than Mexico are being repatriated to their countries of citizenship. which are predominately located in Central America. I repeat. only 3 percent are being repatriated back home. According to the former head of Enforcement and Removal Operations for ICE. the Immigration and Customs Enforcement agency. Gary Mead: Its taking a year or more in some places for people to come up on a hearing and many times. they dont have an attorney. or theyve lost an attorney. and they get an extension. and maybe its two years before they have a hearing. And in the interim period. they enroll in school. or they get a job. or they are reunited with family members. and then they are no longer an enforcement priority. That is significant. Even if after 2 or 3 years a judge finally orders removalassuming the individuals show up in court at allmany illegal immigrants simply ignore that order. and having been here for a period of years. no one makes them leave. As former ICE Director John Sandweg said: "If you are a runofthemill immigrant here illegally. your odds of getting deported are close to zero." Yesterday. Byron York published in the Washington Examiner the findings of Jessica Vaughan. Director of Policy Studies at the Center for Immigration Studies. which shows that the United States deported a total of 802 minors to Guatemala. Honduras. and El Salvador in 2011. 677 in 2012. and down to 496 last year. Weighed against the tens of thousands pouring in. it is clear that once again the reality on the groundnot merely rumor. talk. or policyof the lax enforcement has influenced decisionmaking in Central America.
Identified stereotypes
Human beings are rational actors and will come if they think they will be granted citizenship.
Keywords matched
immigration border crossing deported illegal aliens illegal immigrants deporting immigrant Immigration

Classification

Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
⚠️ Yes
Confidence
90%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
JEFFERSON SESSIONS
Party
R
Chamber
S
State
AL
Gender
M
Date
2014-06-24
Speech ID
1130102611
Paragraph
#3
← Prev Next →