Session #113 · 2013–15

Speech #1130100688

Fear makes people succumb to their basest instincts instead of rising to their noblest ambitions. Fear paralyzes us during times when we need to be taking action. House Republicans are afraid of immigration. They are not only afraid of voting on an immigration bill. they are even afraid of introducing legislation on immigration. Let me give you some examples. June 2013. Congressman JOE HECK says he was going to introduce immigration reform that would address our broken system. In December of 2013. Republican Congressman HECK announced he would not be introducing any immigration bill of any kind. April 2014. Congressman JOE BARTON said he was going to introduce major immigration legislation. The bill was never introduced. ERIC CANTOR. who just this week claimed that his position on immigration never wavered. said last year he was going to introduce legislation to "deal with the kids who did not break any laws and themselves came into this country in many cases unbeknownst to them." This legislation was also never introduced. Finally. House Republican leadership has repeatedly announced they "think we finally have the policy right on immigration." But again. we have seen no bill even introduced. much less voted on. House Republicans are so afraid of immigration that they have handed the policy and leadership gavel to STEVE KING. who compares immigrants to dogs and livestock and who claims immigration is a slowmotion holocaust. ERIC CANTOR is actually right that his position on immigration reform never wavered. His rhetoric was often proreform. but his legislative and voting record was always antireform. CANTOR never introduced or voted for a single immigration bill that would help a single immigrant. But he loved to vaguely reference the need for immigration reform when asked about it. That has been the real Republican Party position on immigration: pretending to be proimmigration reform rhetorically. but never. never permit a Republican to actually introduce immigration reform legislation and definitely never allow immigration reform legislation to come to a vote. This is because House Republicans may claim to disagree with STEVE KINGs words. but they certainly do not seem to disagree with STEVE KINGs policy objectives. They do not want immigration reform that will rationalize our legal immigration system and create a path to legality for those who are already here. Instead. they support the failed and tragic policies of selfdeportation for the people who are already here. and they want to reduce legal immigration to a trickle for the people who wish to come here and contribute to our society. Two nights ago. when I watched our gritty U.S. soccer team win an amazing game against Ghana. I saw an amazing team effort coached by an energetic German immigrant whose tactics and decisions helped the United States prevail in the final stages of an incredible. compelling game. Did Republicans watch the same game and ask: Why is an immigrant coaching our team? These last 2 weeks. I watched the San Antonio Spurs play some of the greatest team basketball anyone has ever seen with players from France.
Identified stereotypes
Steve King compares immigrants to dogs and livestock.
Keywords matched
immigration immigrant immigrants

Classification

Target group
Also mentioned
Germans
Sentiment
Mixed
Stereotyping
⚠️ Yes
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Economic contributor Cultural enrichment

Speaker & context

Speaker
CHARLES SCHUMER
Party
D
Chamber
S
State
NY
Gender
M
Date
2014-06-18
Speech ID
1130100688
Paragraph
#2
← Prev Next →