Session #113 · 2013–15

Speech #1130088966

Not only are citizens hurt by permitting illegals to cut in front of the line. but it is also a slap in the face to those who continue to wait their turn to come to America. When we give in to trying to placate and trying to meet the interests of people who come here illegally. it is done at the expense of those people who are waiting in line and want to be American citizens and want to obey our laws and want to come here legally. Yes. illegal immigrants hurt the American people and hurt legal immigrants even worse. Earlier this year. President Obamas 2012 unilateral deferral of deportation for certain illegal immigrants. essentially an amnesty decree. caused huge delays for thousandsthat is thousands who are here legally seeking green cards. seeking to have government employees do their job and to actually make the immigration system work. Our government employees were servicing illegal immigrants at the expense of legal immigrants. They got it totally backwards. And that is the argument that we face today. It has a lot of things totally backwards. While it is concerning that the Presidents actions appear to be politicalwhich is this effort that we saw to try to appeal to the various segments of our population in order to conduct policy in the interest of illegal immigrantsI am most troubled by the fact that. basically. our President would defy the rule of law and congressional intent by unilaterally granting preferential treatment to those immigrants who are here illegally. And our President then. without congressional intent or any rule of law behind it. actually shifted the services of our government to service the needs of people who are here illegally at the expense of those people who are here legally. Nearly 4.5 million mostly legal immigrants are currently caught up in the backlog of our bureaucratic immigration process. That is 4.5 million people who we need to be concerned about. They are part of the American family. They have come here as part of those 1 million legal immigrants that we have coming in. but yet they end up waiting decadesyears. and sometimes decadesto make sure that their papers are processed so that they can become citizens. The last thing we need to doand unfortunately this administration has been doing itis shift over the work effort and the time and the resources that are necessary to help these people who come here legally become citizens. shift that over to trying to service those people who are here illegally and have thumbed their nose at our law. A policy which hurts those who follow the law and hurts those who are U.S. citizens and then rewards illegal and dishonest behavior is going to have some pretty bad consequences. We are not fooled by the rhetoricand no one should be fooled by the rhetoricthat we need to have "comprehensive immigration reform" and that it will in some way impact in a positive way what I have been talking about this afternoon. What they really mean when they talk about "comprehensive immigration reform"-what they really meanis "amnesty." They dont want to use that word because the American people learned what that was all about. What they are really doing is rewarding those who have broken the law. and they do so at the expense of American citizens and. yes. at the expense of those immigrants who are here legally. As the saying goes: Fool me once. shame on you. fool me twice. shame on me. Mr. Speaker. we have already been fooled once. Amnesty has been tested. and it has proven to be a failed policy. In fact. it has served only as a catalyst for chain migration. which has compounded many of the horrific economic and social challenges that we face today. So we have already had an amnesty in the past. and we know what it has done to the challenges that we had then. It has made them worse. And now we have ended up with. as I say. horrific economic and social challenges. I am. of course. speakingwhen I talk about the amnesty of the pastof the 1986 immigration reform bill. where Congress infamously promised President Reagan that they would enhance border security in exchange for an amnesty on the behalf of nearly 3 million illegal immigrants then residing in the United States. Needless to say. border security was never enhanced and. needless to say. many more than the 3 million that we were supposedly talking about were legalized through chain migration. And millions upon millions more would continue to illegally flock to our country. Why? Because they saw that those people who had come here illegally ended up becoming naturalized. ended up being put in front of the line of those people who were waiting diligently in other countries to come here legally. Thus. it created a major increase in the flood of illegals into our country. As common sense would dictate. the U.S. Government cannot continue to send this type of mixed message. the message which basically says we are going to reward that person who is here illegally by making him a citizen. putting him through the process actually even before those people who have come here legally. and anybody who gets here illegally. we will reward them with citizenship. They will then have the rights of Americans for education. for health care and the opportunities that are abundant here for American citizens and legal immigrants. Well. if we continue to say anybody who can get to this country illegally or not is going to have those benefits. that is a mixed message if we expect that illegal immigration is going to be halted or in some way that the people overseas who are considering will hesitate to come here. In fact. we are rewarding those who made it here. Without expecting the legal immigration invasion of our country to increase. we actually gave people the incentive to come here illegally. Illegal immigration only dramatically jumped after the 1986 amnesty deal. setting the path for our current predicament. And what is our current predicament? We have social and economic dislocation that is harming the American people. especially middle class working people.
Keywords matched
border security immigration green cards naturalized illegal immigration illegal immigrants Illegal immigration chain migration deportation illegal immigrantsI immigrants

Classification

Also mentioned
legal immigrants American citizens
Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Economic threat Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
DANA ROHRABACHER
Party
R
Chamber
H
State
CA
Gender
M
Date
2014-05-01
Speech ID
1130088966
Paragraph
#1
← Prev Next →