Session #111 · 2009–11

Speech #1110036726

I leel that aid to the victims is critical. Nevertheless. I am disgusted by the process by which this legislation came to the floor and by the immigrationrelated provisions in the bill. This is an appropriations bill. It is not the place to write new immigration law or to include seriously flawed drivers license provisions. The Republicans are clamoring in the Senate about the lack of up or down votes on judges and. today. they denied the House not only an up or down vote on the socalled "Real ID" Act. but even a real debate on this issue. The immigration sections are seriously flawed. They impose onerous restrictions on foreign nationals in the U.S.. not to mention upon American citizens. and slap a massive unfunded mandate upon the states. Shortly after this legislation takes effect. I can only imagine that. instead of more licensed drivers on the roads. there will be less. Instead of safer roads. we will have more reckless drivers operating completely outside of our laws. America is a nation of immigrants and our strength is in our diversity. We are founded upon the people who have come from all corners of the globe and are continually enriched by the unique strengths that they add to our national mosaic. We must not undermine the careful balance our nation has struck. I. theretore. strongly oppose these ID and immigrationrelated sections and pledge to fight hard in the future to remove the offensive provisions from the law. in the end. as a legislator. I must vote on the bill in front of me. and in this instance I must vote for the vital funding contained in this bill. But.
Keywords matched
immigrants immigration immigrationrelated

Classification

Target group
Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
ELIOT ENGEL
Party
D
Chamber
H
State
NY
Gender
M
Date
2009-05-04
Speech ID
1110036726
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →