Session #111 · 2009–11

Speech #1110023519

Madam Speaker. I rise today to introduce the Access to Justice Act. A bill to amend the Immigration and Nationality Act to establish a right for an alien to file a motion to reopen a case in removal proceedings if the alien can demonstrate that counsel or a certified representative provided deficient performance. In one of his last actions as Attorney General. Michael Mukasey ruled that immigrants have no constitutional right to effective legal representation in deportation hearings. After more than 20 years of precedent in special immigration courts overseen by the Justice Department. those now facing deportation have no remedy for the errors committed by incompetent. inattentive lawyers. or even those who claim to be lawyers. This 11th hour regulation not only goes counter to what has already been established by a long line of decisions in the federal courts and the Board of Immigration Appeals but also is a matter of equal protection/due process. In fact. the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit stated in an opinion. "Vulnerable immigrants are preyed upon by unlicensed notaries and unscrupulous appearance attorneys who extract fees in exchange for false promises and shoddy. ineffective representation." The Supreme Court has found that noncitizens are ineligible for court appointed counsel in civil cases. Removal proceedings are not considered criminal and therefore. immigrants who are in the process of being deported must find their own counsel. Judge Katzmann on the Second Circuit Court of Appeals said in a recent New York Times article. "Justice should not depend on the income level of immigrants." A study in the Georgetown Journal of Legal Ethics found that only 35% of individuals in removal proceedings had counsel. yet asylum seekers who have counsel are three times more likely to succeed in their claim compared to those without representation. Because of this Supreme Court decision incompetent legal representation is now "discretionary" and thus unreviewable. So the former Attorney General. the final arbiter in immigration cases. decided in his final hours in office without any consultation with Congress that the 6th amendment right to counsel only applies to criminals. not to noncriminals who have privately retained lawyers in civil removal proceedings. Imagine in our great melting pot of an immigrant nation a decision that gives greater access to justice to those who might have committed a felony more than to those who want to be Americans. When a lawyer fails to show up to court or forgets to file the required paperwork. the individual being deported will have no legal right to appeal on the grounds of deficient counsel. That is why I am introducing The Access to Justice Act. a bill that would create a legislative fix to the Mukasey decision. This bill creates a right to file a motion to reopen a removal case if deficient performance of counsel can be demonstrated.
Identified stereotypes
Vulnerable immigrants are preyed upon by unlicensed notaries and unscrupulous appearance attorneys who extract fees in exchange for false promises and shoddy. ineffective representation.
Keywords matched
immigrants asylum seekers immigrant noncitizens immigration deportation deported Immigration

Classification

Target group
Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
⚠️ Yes
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Legal / procedural Victim

Speaker & context

Speaker
Unknown
Party
—
Chamber
—
State
—
Gender
—
Date
2009-03-19
Speech ID
1110023519
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →