Session #111 · 2009–11

Speech #1110018859

Pt. 5 March 9. 2009 of Labor Statistics reported that the unemployment rate in February jumped to 8.1 percent. 651.000 jobs lost in January. which equates to roughly 12 million workers without jobs. This is the highest unemployment rate since the mid 1980s. Immigration by illegal immigrants and other poorly educated aliens has had a depressing effect on the standard of living of lower skilled American workers. This is a matter of very little dispute. The U.S. Commission on Immigration Reform. chaired by the late civil rights pioneer Barbara Jordan. found that immigration of unskilled immigrants "comes at a cost to U.S. workers." The Center for Immigration Studies has estimated that such immigration has reduced the wage of average nativeborn workers in a lowskilled occupation by 12 percent or almost $2.000 annually. Is there any doubt about that? I do not think so. In addition. Harvard economist George Borjas. himself a Cuban refugee. an immigrant who came here as a young man. has estimated that immigration in recent decades has reduced wages of nativeborn workers with a high school degree by 8.2 percent. It also takes jobs. A report in todays USA Today cites to studies by the Heritage Foundation and the Center for Immigration Studies which found that according to their estimate. out of the 2.5 million jobs projected to be created by the stimulus plan. 300.000 would be going to people illegally here. That is approximately 15 percent. Doris Meissner. in February of this year. former head of the INS under President Clinton. said this. "Mandatory." this amendment does not make anything mandatory. but she said: Mandatory employer verification must be at the center of legislation to combat illegal immigration . . . the EVerify system provides a valuable tool for employers who are trying to comply with the law. EVerify also provides an opportunity to determine the best electronic means to implement verification requirements. The Administration should support reauthorization of EVerify and expand the program . . . This is an expert in this. She knows that EVerify is the cornerstone of the entire effort to clear a lawful system of immigration. Mr. Alexander Aleinikoff. the Clinton administration INS official and President Obamas transition team member. called it a "myth" that "there is little or no competition between undocumented workers and American workers." It is a myth. Of course it does. Of course it pulls down the wages of lower hardworking American citizens.
Identified stereotypes
Generalization that illegal immigrants and poorly educated aliens have a depressing effect on the standard of living of lower skilled American workers.
Keywords matched
immigrants illegal immigration undocumented immigrant EVerify immigration refugee illegal immigrants Immigration

Classification

Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
⚠️ Yes
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Economic threat

Speaker & context

Speaker
JEFFERSON SESSIONS
Party
R
Chamber
S
State
AL
Gender
M
Date
2009-03-09
Speech ID
1110018859
Paragraph
#3
← Prev Next →