Session #111 · 2009–11

Speech #1110007373

If we are going to help families with children. we ought to be fair about it. This bill we are considering expands the childrens health plan. The current law in America certainly covers American citizens. but the Federal money is not allowed to be used for noncitizens. That is basically part of our immigration deal. When folks come here and they are sponsored. the agreement is that for 5 years they take care of themselves and they are not a burden on the American taxpayer. But the bill we are debating today changes that law. It gives benefits. health care. to noncitizens at the expense of middleclass working Americans. I do not want to take that away. That is not what this bill is about. my amendment. I am not changing anything this bill already offers. But what this amendment does Is it gives every American family with children. qualifying children under the childrens health plan we are debating. an abovetheline deduction of up to $1.500. And what it is. it gives American citizens the same benefit we are giving nonAmericans. noncitizens. in this underlying bill. We do not ask the Government to pay for their health care. We say. as a matter of fairness. we are not going to make them pay income taxes on what they have to spend on health care for their children.
Keywords matched
noncitizens immigration

Classification

Target group
Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Economic threat Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
JIM DEMINT
Party
R
Chamber
S
State
SC
Gender
M
Date
2009-01-29
Speech ID
1110007373
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →