Session #111 · 2009–11

Speech #1110006040

In other words. maybe people who can afford it better and have higher incomes decide: Why should I pay out of my pocket when I can go on the public program? I think it is wrong to throw aside something that we had in 2007 that was going to keep people in private coverage and encourage them to go where we do not have enough money to cover children who do not have anything. Neither bill vetoed by President Bush in 2007 included a provision to allow States to be reimbursed at the Medicaid and SCHIP levels for legal immigrant children and pregnant women. I am not going to go into this issue in depth because I did that yesterday. But this issue does open a difficult and contentious Immigration issue that does need to be brought up. One of the reasons I was able to support the compromise of 2007 on the Childrens Health Insurance Program was it did not contain the controversial provisions to direct Federal resources to the coverage of legal immigrants. I said yesterday how in some instances it could end up covering people who have come here illegally. In the 1996 welfare reform bill. we required the sponsors of legal immigrants to sign an affidavit that they would provide for those immigrants for the first 5 years they were in the country. With this bill we are allowing sponsors to go back on that commitment. If you have a contractual relationship. it seems to me to be only morally right that the Federal Government would want to have that moral contractnot encourage ditching it. But this bill would allow that to happen. We are allowing sponsors to go back on that commitment they made to the taxpayers of this country. Additionally. the $1.3 billion the bill provides for these immigrants who were promised they would be taken care of is money that could be far better spent on poor. uninsured American children. It is a little bit the same argument I just gave about crowdout. If you have people on private insurance. then save the public money for people who are currently eligible for public programs. but who are not insured.
Keywords matched
immigrant immigrants Immigration

Classification

Target group
Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
90%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Economic threat Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
CHARLES GRASSLEY
Party
R
Chamber
S
State
IA
Gender
M
Date
2009-01-27
Speech ID
1110006040
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →