Session #111 · 2009–11

Speech #1110005340

We plan to raise taxes on cigarettes. a tax that the American Cancer Society says could prevent nearly 1 million deaths and keep nearly 2 million children from starting to smoke. a tax with health savings that could ultimately decrease government costs for government health care programs. a tax that the Congressional Budget Office confirms will fully offset this bill so as not to add to our deficit. I dont think that would be a good reason to deny vulnerable children the safety and security of health insurance. During the course of this discussion. some Members have tried to make this debate about illegal immigration. It is not. We should not permit the very difficult issue of illegal immigration to affect this bill to deny millions of children the health care they badly need. That would be a grave mistake. That would be a wrong. Let me be very clear: Only children who are legally in the United States are eligible to receive coverage under Medicaid or the Childrens Health Insurance Program. They must document their immigration status. Medicaid agencies use information provided by the Bureau of Citizenship and Immigration Services to confirm the status of 55. Pt. 2 1569 legal immigrants applying for benefits. Further. this bill does not even require States to cover legal immigrant children. It simply provides and supports that option. Legal immigrants pay taxes. they serve in our Armed Forces. and just like the rest of us. they play by the rules. They are our future citizens. and insuring their children makes sense. This was the law until 1996 when sweeping restrictions affecting legal immigrants were made. Since 1996. we have become wiser. and many of those restrictions have been reversed on a bipartisan basis by Congress. The provision in this legislation covering legal immigrants is fully consistent with that trend back to 1996 levels. This Nation is slowly emerging from a dark time when our ideals and our virtues were too often hidden in the shadows. when we let our fear overcome our principles and our better judgment. when we lost sight of our priorities and left millions of people in the cold and millions of children uninsured. That time can end now.
Keywords matched
illegal immigration immigrants immigrant immigration Immigration

Classification

Also mentioned
legal immigrants
Sentiment
Positive
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
95%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Humanitarian Legal / procedural Economic contributor

Speaker & context

Speaker
SHELDON WHITEHOUSE
Party
D
Chamber
S
State
RI
Gender
M
Date
2009-01-27
Speech ID
1110005340
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →