Our constituents showing the vast disconnect between themselves and the beltway elite started making their views known with the benefits of highpaid lobbyists. Like most Americans. I was delighted to watch the immigration proposal go down to defeat in the U.S. Senate. First and foremost. it demonstrated how widely unpopular the notion of granting amnesty to illegal aliens is with the American people. More importantly. however. Congress rejection of the bill may have signified the high watermark for advocates of ever increasing levels of immigration. both legal and illegal. into the United States. Supporters of the Presidents immigration plan were forced to even change the rhetoric of the debate as they tried desperately to invent a nonoffensive euphemism for amnesty. We heard it referred to as "earned legalization." as "comprehensive reform" and as "regularization." Despite their efforts. however. Americans made it quite clear that they opposed amnesty. Its not surprising. but the amnesty proposal contained within the bill isnt the only fuel that fueled the grassroots brush fire that killed that bill. Dramatic increases in legal immigration levels proved to be nearly as unpopular as amnesty. and it also contributed to the demise of the legislation. Public concerns about dramatically increased levels of legal immigration helped to derail a similar Senate proposal in 2006 after Robert Rector of the Heritage Foundation analyzed how many foreigners the bill would allow into the United States over the next 20 years. some 60 million people. Sheer numbers began to transcend anecdotal stories about friendly immigrant neighbors on the minds of the American public. Indeed. the protracted debate over immigration has voters increasingly focused on what is a very reasonable question: What kind of immigration policy serves our national interest? Not surprisingly. few have stepped forward to defend the status quo or the massive increases proposed by the Senate leadership or the President. Mr. Rector penned a report applicable to that years Senate concoction. Despite all the talk about how critical lowskilled immigrants are to economic growth. his study confirmed what many already knew. that lowskilled legal and illegal immigrants are a net cost to taxpayers. not a net gain. just as their nativeborn counterparts are. The Senate bill would have cost our children and grandchildren $2.5 trillion due to amnesty provisions and increased levels of legal immigration authorized by the legislation. Again. it was Mr. Rectors analysis that deeply shook the publics confidence in the Senates credibility in handling the issue. Once more. the question about legal immigration became relevant in light of that information. Now. Im not saying that America is ready to install a "no vacancy" sign on the Statue of Liberty. At the same time. we cannot discount the increasingly disconcerting public feeling that honoring our tradition of immigration while decreasing the yearly total of immigrants to more sustainable levels are not mutually exclusive goals. A significant decrease similar to that one in the Commission on Immigration Reform advocated in the mid1990s would be a good first step toward creating a more orderly and sustainable immigration policy in America. such as. by the way. eliminating chain migration and the visa lottery. I continue to believe that a return to traditional immigration levels as well as stepped up enforcement can be won in a matter of months and years. not decades. For one reason I believe that this is what will happen in this seminal legislative moment in my House tenure is that Mr. SENSENBRENNER. the chairman of the Judiciary Committee. began the process in late 2005 of crafting a comprehensive immigration reform billthe Border Protection. Antiterrorism. and Illegal Immigration Control Act. It passed 239 to 182. Not only did the enforcement bill first receive broad bipartisan support on the final passage but so did standalone amendments to build border fencing and to reduce legal immigration by eliminating the Visa Diversity program. Our immigration caucus played a vital role in making sure that not so much as a sense of Congress was allowed to suggest that we needed guest workers. There is still. of course. much to do. I am proud of the accomplishments of the caucus. I am proud of the accomplishments that my colleagues and I. who have fought for immigration reform. have made to this point in time. Certainly. it is the reason. by the way. that I ran for the Presidency of the United States. for the Republican nomination for the Presidency of the United States. With little idea. in fact no idea. that I would actually become the President of the United States in that process. I was nonetheless inspired to do what I did and run for the nomination for President in order to force the people who were on the stage with me during that period of time to address this issue. There was a reluctance in doing so. I know I started the process out in February of last year and ended it in December. and between that time that I started in February to December. there was a complete change in the way each person who was running for that nomination addressed the issue of immigration. Finally. every single person. including the present nominee of the party. agreed that we had to secure the borders first. We must do that.
Keywords matched
immigrants visa immigrant Border Protection Visa chain migration illegal aliens Illegal Immigration illegal immigrants immigration Immigration