Session #109 · 2005–07

Speech #1090042173

The irony of this amendment would be amusing if its implications were not so serious. On one hand. we are providing SCAAP funding to help our States and localities incarcerate criminal aliens that pose a danger to our communities: yet. on the other hand. the gentlemans amendment would make it harder for our State and local law enforcement agencies to catch criminals in the first place. Many law enforcement agencies have carefully built a relationship of trust with their immigrant communities over the years. If we were to damage this trust by confusing a States law enforcement roles with Federal immigration enforcement roles. we would be hampering the ability of our police departments to perform their primary function: protecting communities from crime. That is why police departments in our districts do not want this amendment. The amendment would have a chilling effect on immigrants willingness to report crimes and cooperate with government overall. because immigrants are less likely to come forward with tips or to testify as witnesses if doing so could lead to deportation or other adverse consequences. The effects of the amendment would be devastating. Law enforcement agencies. whether performing counterterrorism or other public safety functions. must rely on cooperation from immigrant communities to operate effectively. Furthermore. the harm of this amendment would extend beyond law enforcement. Public health could be harmed if. out of fear of being reported to the INS. immigrants were reluctant to make use of State and local services. For instance. I imagine many communities throughout the Nation consider it in the best interest of all of its residents. documented or not. to ensure that everyone gets a vaccine shot for their children from city hospitals. If an undocumented person were presented a choice between deportation and risking illness. I am sure that person would make a choice that is not in the best interest of the community. In closing. please understand law enforcement gets information and wants information from the immigrant community. If they now become Federal immigration officers. that information will not be forthcoming.
Keywords matched
undocumented immigrant immigration immigrants deportation

Classification

Target group
Sentiment
Mixed
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
90%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Security threat Humanitarian

Speaker & context

Speaker
JOSE SERRANO
Party
D
Chamber
H
State
NY
Gender
M
Date
2005-06-16
Speech ID
1090042173
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →