Prior to proposing the procedure reforms. one in four cases were decided in favor of the opinion. Since then. only 1 in 10 is decided in favor of the alien. and there is no opinion. just an affirmation. It is important to note that a wide number of organizations and academics in immigration law believe that these affirmances without opinion by singlemember review has created bad legal and administrative precedent and an incentive to rubberstamp immigration judges decisions. Affirmance without opinion is much faster and easier than writing a decision and creates an incentive. whether conscious or unconscious. for board members to meet case processing guidelines by affirming removal orders. notwithstanding the merits of the appeal. The rights of the petitioner and due process requires a thorough review. That is what the appeals process is all about. Moreover. intellectual rigor in decisionmaking may be diminished because board members no longer need to articulate the basis for their decisions. They need only to decide whether they agree with the result ultimately reached by the immigration judge. A panel of three board members is far more likely to catch an error below than a single board member. In the immigration context. there is only one administrative hearing before the case reaches the board. Other administrative agencies that employ singlemember review have several layers of administrative process. That is why it is important to change or to look into this procedure at the Bureau of Immigration Appeals. Singlemember review makes it difficult for the board itself to determine whether its members are making errors. The courts of appeal. when such review is available. similarly lack guidance when reviewing the decisions of the immigration judges and the board. Now I would like to reaffirm my position. which is to suggest that the idea of a de novo hearing in the Federal District Court and the Court of Appeals is an option that should be considered important by giving the Bureau. if you will. more substance in its determination.
Keywords matched
Immigration immigration