Session #109 · 2005–07

Speech #1090036206

Let us work together harmoniously to secure the American borders in the right way. and let us allow the United States military to serve their Nation and defend this country in the way that they have been trained to do it. not water down their duties and add to the danger of civilian/military conflict. I rise in opposition to this amendment. It would authorize the Secretary of Defense to assign members of the Army. the Navy. the Air Force. and the Madnes to assist the Department of Homeland Security in the performance of border protection functions. I share my colleagues desire for a secure border. but this is not the way to do it. Border security is a civilian responsibility that has been assigned to the Department of Homeland Security. not to the military. I also want to express my disapproval of permitting civilian volunteers such as the minutemen to assist in securing our borders. We can provide the additional support the Department needs by increasing the number of border patrol agents. Soldiers are not necessary or desirable as border patrolmen. Putting troops on the border would violate the Posse Comitatus Act of 1878. which prohibits the United States military from patrolling within United States borders. The United States military is stretched thin from wars in Afghanistan and Iraq. Putting troops at our border would further strain our capabilities abroad. Migrants are not enemy combatants. They are seeking better economic opportunities for their families. Their plight should not be combated with military force. but rather with immigration reform. The United States Border Patrol actively cooperates with the military in many areasfrom infrastructure construction to the implementation of new hightech monitoring such as unmanned aerial vehicles. The Border Patrol already knows when and how to ask for cooperation from the military. The military is not trained to operate in United States civilian communities. as is the case with much of the border. More than 10 million people live along the American side of the Mexico border.
Keywords matched
border protection immigration Border security border patrol Border Patrol Migrants

Classification

Target group
Sentiment
Neutral
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Economic contributor Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
Unknown
Party
—
Chamber
—
State
—
Gender
—
Date
2005-05-25
Speech ID
1090036206
Paragraph
#1
← Prev Next →