Session #109 · 2005–07

Speech #1090032698

I rise to bring a very important issue before the Committee of the Whole by way of an amendment designated as "JacksonLee #75." I would like to once again thank the distinguished Chairman of the Appropriations Subcommittee on Homeland Security and the Ranking Member for showing their awareness of the issue of border violence as one that rises to a level that requires Federal oversight by agreeing to the amendment that I offered yesterday during House consideration of the appropriations measure. H.R. 2360. I also thank the Chairman of the Committee on Homeland Security for his showing of commitment to addressing this issue by agreeing to collaborate with the Ranking Member from Mississippi and me to craft a bipartisan letter to the Department of Homeland Security to request the collection of data on this mater. "JacksonLee #75" is based on the same premise of that amendment. and given that the appropriations measure has placed spending limitations with respect to national border patrol. it would only be logical and prudent for the authorization measure to emphasize the legislative intent to clearly define. monitor. and control this issue before it becomes an expenditure. The purpose of this amendment is to put the American people on notice that the "Minuteman Project" has proposed to enter multiple borders in order to monitor for illegal border crossings. American Federation of Govemment Employees (AFGE) Local No. 3332 and the Association for Residency and Citizenship of America (ARCA) support this important amendment that will prevent impediment to DHSs border security functions as well as the development of negative issues if groups such as the Minutemen attempt to enforce immigration law. The Minuteman Project has good intentions. but we object to the potential negative social. legal. and economic impact that it can have on the Texas borders. The problem of porousness of the borders is a Federal Government problem. It is a Department of Homeland Security (DHS) problem. DHS has legal jurisdiction over the borders: therefore. it is DHS that must address our border security needs. An unofficial. untrained. and uncontrolled militia is the wrong answer for a problem that is within the Federal Governments responsibility. If the job is not being done sufficiently. we must look to Congress and the Executive Branch to exercise oversight and to improve performance. The Minuteman Project is headed for the Texas borders. and its presence will be the recipe for danger. conflict. and increased legal enforcement costs for the Federal Government. The Houston Chronicle reported on May 12 that the controversial group that began as a monthlong engagement along the Arizona border plans to enter Texas to operate its hunt for illegal border crossings. Other media and eyewitnesses have suggested that many of the participants in the Minuteman Project have carried firearms. incited retaliatory measures by gang members. incited more groups to organize in a similar fashion along other American borders. and created a situation that suggests potential constraints on the individual civil rights of undocumented persons. The arrival of this group to Texas is an example of what we feared during its initial engagement during the month of Aprilpropagation in other borders. Empowerment of unofficial. untrained militia to carry out the functions of the Federal Government instead of simply improving the staffing situation at the Customs and Border Patrol and the Immigration. Customs. and Enforcement Agencies is a dereliction of duty and a condoning of potential vigilantism. Several differences between the United StatesMexico border of Arizona and Texas make it potentially injurious for the arrival of the Minutemen.
Keywords matched
undocumented border security immigration Immigration border crossing border patrol Border Patrol

Classification

Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
95%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Security threat Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
SHEILA JACKSON LEE
Party
D
Chamber
H
State
TX
Gender
F
Date
2005-05-18
Speech ID
1090032698
Paragraph
#1
← Prev Next →