Session #109 · 2005–07

Speech #1090028909

Republican conferees dropped the important amendment from the text of this bill. As troubled as I am by the Republican majoritys actions on Iraq. I am perhaps more disturbed by what they decided to do on immigration. and how they went about it. Republicans tacked the socalled REAL ID immigration legislation onto this emergency supplemental that is to provide funding for our troops. REAL ID imposes dramatic new burdens on the States and substantially alters the immigration and asylum laws in ways that this Nation may soon come to regret the action taken by this body. For the House to selfrighteously say that on appropriations bills they will allow no authorizing legislation. people can always waive this REAL IDthis is the mother of all authorizing legislation on an appropriations bill. This REAL ID Act makes reckless and unwise changes to our laws with respect to the environment. refugees. judicial review and. most of all. States rights. It is essentially antiimmigrant legislation couched in the language of antiterrorism. The Wall Street Journal. not the bastion of the socalled liberal press. said the changes made by REAL ID "have long occupied the wish list of antiimmigration lawmakers 51. Pt. 7 9035 and activists." That is the Wall Street Journal. REAL ID will make it much more difficult for individuals fleeing persecution to seek asylum in the United States. will sharply reduce the ability of the Federal courts to rein in overzealous or illwilled administration officials. and will give the Secretary of Homeland Security unprecedented authority to waive environmental and other laws. REAL ID could compromise the privacy of American citizens. create long lines at local DMVs. and make it harder for States and the Federal Government to keep track of who is in our country. In short. REAL ID may make us less rather than more safe. As troubling as what the majority did on immigration is the way they went about it. Republicans tacked on REAL ID knowing full well immigration issues had nothing to do. as I have said before. with the underlying legislation and that REAL ID had never. ever been considered in the Senate. either in the Judiciary Committee. the committee of jurisdiction. I believe. or on the Senate floor. Compounding matters.
Keywords matched
immigration refugees antiimmigration seek asylum antiimmigrant asylum laws

Classification

Target group
Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
90%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Legal / procedural Security threat

Speaker & context

Speaker
HARRY REID
Party
D
Chamber
S
State
NV
Gender
M
Date
2005-05-10
Speech ID
1090028909
Paragraph
#1
← Prev Next →