I appreciate my Senate colleagues support of this measure and look forward to working together to move this as standalone legislation in the near future. It is my hope that the administration will publicly address their concerns with this bill so that we may move swiftly to enact the very important provisions that will help alleviate the ongoing genocide. I am also disappointed that such sweeping immigration provisions were 51. Pt. 7 9025 included in this bill without adequate debate or scrutiny. What concerned me most of all about the REAL ID bill is that it undermines Americas moral authority by turning away legitimate asylum seekers fleeing tyranny. This language was added based on a claim that our asylum system can be used by terrorists to enter the country. This is not the case. However. I would like to thank my colleague Chairman SPECTER for working diligently to successfully soften some of the harsher language in the asylum provisions. As originally drafted. the REAL ID Act would have created significant and additional barriers for refugees fleeing persecution to obtain asylum. REAL ID would have greatly increased a refugees burden of proof to establish their eligibility for asylum. At the whim of an immigration judges discretion. refugees would be required to produce corroborative evidence of their claims of persecution or prove that the central intent of their persecutors was to punish them for their race. religion or political beliefs even in cases where the refugees testimony was already credible. The facts are quite obvious: persecutors are not going to issue official documents explaining their actions. In addition. proving the mindset of those who carry out killings. torture and other abuse is next to impossible. Even if this were possible. those who flee a country often times dont have time to gather up the proper documentation they may later need in an American immigration court. The incorporated revisions would make an immigration judge take into account the totality of the circumstances when evaluating an applicants claim and would not be able to discard a claim for subjective reasons. I want to clarify that the triers of fact must consider all relevant factors and base any adverse credibility determinations on a consideration of all of those factors. The findings must be reasonable. It would not be reasonable to find a lack of credibility based on inconsistencies. inaccuracies or falsehoods that do not go to the heart of the asylum claim without other evidence that the asylum applicant is attempting to deceive the trier of fact. I also understand that when assessing demeanor. triers of fact must take into consideration the individual circumstances of the asylum applicant. such as his or her cultural background. educational background. gender. state of mind. history of trauma. and other factors. I remain concerned about how the asylum provisions will affect the adjudication of claims by children. Adjudicators cannot realistically hold these children to the same burden of proof and standards of persuasion as adult asylumseekers.
Identified stereotypes
Claim that asylum system can be used by terrorists to enter the country.