Session #109 · 2005–07

Speech #1090028870

And indeed. I dont think we are doing enough to secure our borders. But sneaking drastic changes to our immigration laws into a mustpass measure supporting our troops is not the way to address these Issues. Opinions are mixed about how effective the REAL ID bill will be in enhancing national security. But regardless of what you might think about the merits of the bill itselfI. for instance. have serious concerns regarding the impact of its asylum provisionsthis is an issue that requires serious debate. Instead. the Republican leadership has completely bypassed the committee process and slipped this controversial and complicated proposal into the emergency supplemental bill. which we will have to approve because it provides the necessary support of our men and women serving in Iraq and Afghanistan as well as the vital relief for the tsunami victims abroad. Immigrants have built New York and this country from the bottom up. Our country was founded by and made stronger by the hard work of immigrants from all different countries. cultures. religions and races. I marvel how our new immigrants remake our land. making it a better place. even as they become new Americans. Just think of how many recent. and expectant immigrants now serve in our Armed Forces. some of whom have made the ultimate sacrifice for our Nation in Iraq and Afghanistan. I am proud that New York is still an epicenter for immigrants. Just like my ancestors came over from Europe many decades ago. the new generations of people just like us are beginning to take root. making our country. our economy. and our culture that much stronger and diverse. So any bill that makes such dramatic changes to our immigration laws should be looked at carefully and considered judiciously. We must never bend in our determination to secure our borders and protect our Nation from harm. But nor can we forget what makes our Nation great. These debates and decisions must be reasoned debates. not takeitorleaveit ultimatums strategically devised for partisan political benefit. There are provisions in this bill. for instance. that will make it harder for people persecuted on the basis of their race. religion. national origin. or gender abroad to pursue asylum and the American dream. There are other provisions that would allow bail bondsmen to play judge and determine which immigrants are dangers to the community. These are major changes to our laws. and we have a system to debate. discuss and vote on such changes. No bill raising so many questions on issues of such fundamental importance should escape an honest debate in the Senate.
Keywords matched
immigrants Immigrants immigration

Classification

Target group
Sentiment
Positive
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
90%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Economic contributor Cultural enrichment Family values

Speaker & context

Speaker
CHARLES SCHUMER
Party
D
Chamber
S
State
NY
Gender
M
Date
2005-05-10
Speech ID
1090028870
Paragraph
#1
← Prev Next →