Session #109 · 2005–07

Speech #1090028861

The Senate must have the opportunity to consider comprehensive reform. not focus on piecemeal measures. And President Bush should lead the way in working with Congress and our allies for solutions that protect our borders. And for solutions that allow our rich history and tradition of immigration to continue. But these supposed solutions cannot come at the expense of our constitutional framework. REAL ID is an unfunded mandate that is punitive. We do not know if any of the provisions will actually make us saferwe just know that they override States rights and undermine civil rights and civil liberties. I believe that it is our duty. as Members of the Senate. to balance national security interests with due process and constitutional rights. yet because we have not had hearings or been able to evaluate this change to our immigration law we do not know the extent of its impact. REAL ID proposes several different and significant changes to our immigration laws. I believe that it is important for the Senate Judiciary Committee to have an opportunity to hold hearings and consider comprehensive legislation that looks at all areas of the law. Then the whole Senate should have the ability to fully debate the issue on the Senate floor. I am disappointed that this controversial measure was added to this must pass legislation. We should be passing an emergency supplemental bill without the harmful REAL ID provision. And then we should turn our attention to real reform and the Senate should proceed to a thoughtful and comprehensive debate on immigration reform that protects our borders and our constitutional mandate.
Keywords matched
immigration

Classification

Target group
Sentiment
Positive
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Legal / procedural Cultural enrichment

Speaker & context

Speaker
BARBARA MIKULSKI
Party
D
Chamber
S
State
MD
Gender
F
Date
2005-05-10
Speech ID
1090028861
Paragraph
#4
← Prev Next →