Session #109 · 2005–07

Speech #1090028840

ID Act is a big step in the wrong direction. The new restrictions on immigration in the REAL ID Act are not necessary to protect national security. Rather. they will only serve to create serious and unjustified hardships for people fleeing persecution and for other noncitizens. Not only that. but the Senate has had no opportunity to consider the REAL ID Act. It is astounding that Congress would enact these significant immigration changes without the United States Senate ever having held a hearing on them. without the Judiciary Committee ever having considered them. and without Senators ever having taken a vote specifically on those reforms or having had an opportunity to offer amendments. Obviously these issues are too important to address them in such a truncated way. Congressional leaders have no business tacking these very significant and controversial changes to immigration law onto an unrelated. mustpass appropriations bill. Clearly. this process was used because these changes could not pass the Senate on their own merit. They had to be added to legislation that contains vital funding for our troops in Iraq. What has happened to the legislative process? I know that some in the other body. and some in the Senate as well. have very strong feelings about these immigration provisions. But strong feelings do not justify abusing the power of the majority and the legislative process in this way. I strongly object to this tactic. Let me explain a few of my concerns with the REAL ID Act. First. this conference report will make it even harder for those fleeing persecution to seek asylum in this country. These changes to asylum law are simply unnecessary. As any attorney who handles asylum cases can tell you. asylum cases are already extremely difficult to prove. In fact. only about 30 percent of asylum applications are granted today. Those seeking asylum in the United States already undergo the highest level of security checks of all foreign nationals who enter this country. and the provisions in this bill will result. I am sure. in the rejection of legitimate applications without making us any safer. The asylum provisions of the REAL ID Act were improved somewhat in conference. and I greatly appreciate the work Senator BROWNBACK did to make changes to the Housepassed version. But the changes do not go far enough to adequately protect asylum seekers. This bill will have real effects on real peoplepeople who will be sent back to countries where they or their families may be harmed or even killed because of their political or religious beliefs. There are also provisions in this bill that would further restrict judicial review in immigration proceedings. This is not the time to downgrade the judicial branchs longstanding role as a check on the abuse of executive branch power. particularly in light of some of the administrations unprecedented actions since September 11. 2001. Noncitizens have borne the burden of many of the administrations egregious civil liberties violations that have occurred since September 11. I believe that we can fight terrorism without compromising our civil liberties. Making it harder for noncitizens to seek judicial review in immigration proceedings is sending exactly the wrong message about the need to respect the Constitution and basic human rights.
Keywords matched
asylum law immigration asylum cases Noncitizens seeking asylum noncitizens seek asylum asylum seekers asylum applications

Classification

Target group
Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Humanitarian Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
Unknown
Party
—
Chamber
—
State
—
Gender
—
Date
2005-05-10
Speech ID
1090028840
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →