ID provisions contain other broad and sweeping changes to laws that go to the core of our national identity. Each year. countless refugees are forced to leave their countries. fleeing persecution. America has always been a haven for those desperate for such protection. At the very beginning of our history. the refugee Pilgrims seeking religious freedom landed on Plymouth Rock. Ever since. we have welcomed refugees. and it has made us a better Nation. Refugees represent the best of American values. They have stood alone. at great personal cost. against hostile governments for fundamental principles like freedom of speech and religion. We have a responsibility to examine our asylum policies carefully. to see that they are fair and just. But. the REAL ID bill tramples this noble tradition and will be devastating for legitimate asylumseekers fleeing persecution. It will make it more difficult for victims fleeing serious human rights abuses to obtain asylum and safety. and could easily lead to their return to their persecutors. Another section of conference report contains a provision that would complete the U.S.-Mexico border fence in San Diego. But it goes much farther than that. It gives the Department of Homeland security unprecedented and unchecked authority to waive all legal requirements necessary to build such fences. not only in San Diego. but anywhere else along our 2.000 mile border with Mexico and our 4.000 mile border with Canada. Building such fences will cost hundreds of millions of dollars. and they still will not stop illegal immigration. What we need are safe and legal avenues for immigrants to come here and work. not more walls. A major additional problem in the REAL ID provisions is that it could result in the deportation even of longtime legal permanent residents. for lawful speech or associations that occurred 20 years ago or more. It raises the burden of proof to nearly impossible levels in numerous cases. A person who made a donation to a humanitarian organization involved in tsunami relief could be deported if the organization or any of its affiliates was ever involved in violence. The burden would be on the donor to prove by clear and convincing evidence that he knew nothing about any of these activities. The spouse and children of a legal permanent resident could also be deported too based on such an accusation. because of their relationship to the donor. The provision could be applied retroactively. so that a permanent resident who had once supported the lawful. nonviolent work of the African National Congress in South Africa. Sinn Fein in Northern Ireland. the Northern Alliance in Afghanistan. or the Contras in Nicaragua would be deportable. It would be no defense to show that the only support was for lawful nonviolent activity. It would be no defense to show that the United States itself supported some of these groups.
Keywords matched
deported refugees deportable immigrants asylum policies refugee deportation illegal immigration border fence Refugees