ID Act would repeal much of our work from last year. and replace it with provisions that impose on State governments unworkable standards for drivers licenses. The REAL ID Act also includes punitive immigration provisions that we rejected last year. and that have no place on an emergency spending bill. Do not be fooled. Our nation is safer if we implement the protections we passed just last December. We must not allow an ideological debate over immigration policy to derail initiatives vital to the war against terrorism. Last year I was privileged to work with my colleagues on both sides of the aisle and in both Chambers to develop antiterrorism and intelligence reform legislation of which we can all be proud. Among other things. the Intelligence Reform Act called for large increases in the numbers of Border Patrol agents. immigration enforcement agents. and detention beds. It strengthened consular procedures for screening visa applicants. It closed a gaping vulnerability by requiring people entering the United States at our land borders to show a passport. And it required minimum Federal standards to ensure that Stateissued drivers licenses are always secure and reliable forms of identification. At the same time. I joined with my fellow conferees to ensure that the intelligence reform bill focused on genuine antiterrorism measures and excluded extraneous measures. In particular. in conference we rejected a number of antiasylum and antiimmigration provisions. The REAL ID Act simply recycles several of the controversial immigration provisions which we rejected last year. When the REAL ID Act was debated on the House floor this year many of its supporters claimed that these provisions had been recommended by the 9/11 Commission. and are essential to the war on terrorism. That is simply not the case. Last October. the 9/11 Commissioners made clear that the immigration provisions in the House bill were irrelevant to fighting terrorism. I would like to quote from a letter the conferees received from Gov. Thomas Kean and Congressman Lee Hamilton. a letter that reflected the unanimous view of the commissioners. Referring to the House provisions on immigration. they said. *We believe strongly that this bill is not the right occasion for tackling controversial immigration and law enforcement issues that go well beyond the Commissions recommendations. We note in this regard that some of these provisions have been advocated in response to Commission recommendations. They are not Commission recommendations." The commissioners then added. "We believe we are better off with broad bipartisan agreement on key recommendations of the Commission in support of border security than taking up a number of controversial provisions that are more central to the question of immigration policy than they are to the question of counterterrorism.*" As the commissioners made clear. the provisions in the REAL ID Act have more to do with immigration than with national security. These are controversial provisions that need to be fully considered by our Judiciary Committee. The legislation would make it harder for refugees fleeing oppressive regimes to get asylum. That provision does not target terrorists because current law already states that no member of a terrorist organization can be eligible for asylum. The REAL ID Act would suspend habeas corpus review in deportation proceedings. Not since the Civil War has habeas corpus been suspended. The House bill would allow the Department of Homeland Security to waive all laws so that fences and barriers can be built on any of our land borders.
Keywords matched
border security immigration refugees visa deportation Border Patrol antiimmigration