Session #109 · 2005–07

Speech #1090022766

ID bill contains other broad and sweeping changes to laws that go to the core of our national identity. If enacted. it would deny judicial review and due process which could result in devastating consequences for immigrants and refugees. By restricting judicial review and habeas corpus. it could force people to be deported before they can challenge basic errors made in their cases. It would deny the constitutionally protected writ of habeas corpus. which has not been changed since the Civil War. Habeas corpus is a fundamental principle of American justice. Its called the "great writ" for a reasonbecause its brought justice to people wrongly detained. Just as absurd. the bill will outsource law enforcement by giving .51. Pt. 5 April 20. 2005 "bounty hunters" unprecedented authority to apprehend and detain immigrants. even if a bond has not been breached. Bonding agents would be given the discretion and decisionmaking power that belongs to judges who have the necessary legal training to make these determinations. A major additional problem in the REAL ID bill is that it could result in the deportation even of longtime legal permanent residents. for lawful speech or associations that occurred twenty years ago or more. It raises the burden of proof to nearly impossible levels in numerous cases. A person who made a donation to a humanitarian organization involved in Tsunami relief could be deported if the organization or any of its affiliates was ever involved in violence. The burden would be on the donor to prove by clear and convincing evidence that he knew nothing about any of these activities. The spouse and children of a legal permanent resident could also be deported too based on such an accusation. because of their relationship to the donor. The provision could be applied retroactively. so that a permanent resident who had once supported the lawful. nonviolent work of the African National Congress in South Africa. Sinn Fein in Northern Ireland. the Northern Alliance in Afghanistan. or the contras in Nicaragua would be deportable. It would be no defense to show that the only support was for lawful nonviolent activity. It would be no defense to show that the United States itself supported some of these groups. More than 600 organizations across the political spectrum oppose this legislation. A broad coalition of religious. immigrant. human rights. and civil liberties groups have expressed their own strong opposition. Also opposing the bill are the National Governors Association. the American Association of Motor Vehicle Administrators. and the National Conference of State Legislators. and a 9/11 family group. the September 11 Families for Peaceful Tomorrows. In these difficult times for our country. we know that the threat of terrorism has not ended. and we must do all we can to enact genuine measures to stop terrorists before they act. and to see that law enforcement officials have the full support they need. The REAL ID bill will not improve these efforts. It will not make us safer or prevent terrorism and it is an invitation to gross abuses. It is a false solution to national and border security. I urge the Senate to oppose the REAL ID bill.
Keywords matched
immigrant border security deportable refugees deported immigrants deportation

Classification

Target group
Also mentioned
Refugees
Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
Unknown
Party
—
Chamber
—
State
—
Gender
—
Date
2005-04-20
Speech ID
1090022766
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →