Mr. Speaker. I rise this evening to begin what I hope will be the start of a constructive dialogue about our Nations immigration laws. There has been a lot of heated rhetoric about this topic in recent months. But what I believe has been lacking from this debate is a discussion of real solutions and an accurate portrayal of the real contribution of our Nations immigrant community. In Congress. on cable shows and in newspaper columns across the country. we witness undocumented workers being unfairly and inaccurately blamed for all of our Nations ills. In fact. it seems as though there are some cable show hosts out there who have made this practice the cornerstone of their programming. Just look at Lou Dobbs and his **Broken Borders" segment. If you ask me. it should be called the "Broken Record" segment. Because night after night after night. it is the same thing. It is about giving a platform to antiimmigrant extremists so they can espouse their misguided. misleading. and often malicious views. Mr. Speaker. I am the first to admit that our Nations immigration system is simply not working. It is not meeting the needs of our Nation. it is damaging families. and it is hurting businesses. But rather than targeting Windexwielding cleaning ladies. we should be talking about practical solutions. Do these individuals actually believe we should deport the more than 10 million undocumented working men and women working in this country? Do they think that is truly the answer? Let us say they say yes. Do they think our Nation has the will or the requisite resources to round up these individuals and ship them all off? If that is the case. I would simply ask them. what would life be without the more than 700.000 undocumented restaurant workers washing dishes and cleaning tables. 250.000 household employees. or the almost 1 million undocumented farm workers? These industries where these workers toil would literally come to a screeching halt if not for their labor. Their absence would cripple entire communities.
Keywords matched
undocumented immigrant antiimmigrant immigration