Session #109 · 2005–07

Speech #1090021474

As a member of the Appropriations Committee and on this floor. I fully support prompt appropriations for our men and women in uniform and for operations necessary in the war on terrorism. AgJOBS is only an installment toward an overall solution to our nations growing problem of illegal immigration. However. it is a significant installment. a logical installment. and one that is fully matured and ready to go forward. I have worked with my colleagues and numerous communities of interest on AgJOBS issues for several years. The amendment I bring forward this week has been. in all its major essentials. wellknown and much discussed in the Senate and the House for more than a year and a half. This bipartisan effort builds upon years of discussion and suggestions among growers. farm worker advocates. Latino and immigration issue advocates. Members of both parties in both Houses of Congress. and others. We have now built the largest bipartisan coalition ever for a single immigration bill. This letter was just delivered this week to Senate offices. There are about 100 more signatures on this letter than a similar letter delivered a year ago. Support for AgJOBS is growing. That support reflects the fact that. in agriculture as in other sectors. the current immigration and labor market system is profoundly broken. An enforcementonly policy is not the answer and doesnt work. The United States has 7.458 miles of land borders and 88.600 miles of tidal shoreline. We can secure those frontiers well but not perfectly. As we have stepped up border enforcement. we have locked undocumented immigrants in this country at least as effectively as we have locked any out. With an estimated 10 million undocumented persons in the United States to find them and flush them out of homes. schools. churches. and work places would mean an intrusion on the civil liberties of Americans that they will not tolerate. We fought our revolution. in part. over troops at our doors and in our homes. History has shown us what does work: A coupling of more secure borders. better internal enforcement. and a guest worker program that faces up to economic reality. The only experience our country has had with a legal farm guest worker programused widely in the 1950s but repealed in the 1960staught us conclusive lessons. While it was criticized on other grounds. that program dramatically reduced illegal immigration from high levels to almost nothing. while meeting labor market needs. AgJOBS is a groundbreaking. necessary part of this balanced. realistic approach. American agriculture has boldly stepped forward and admitted the problem. AgJOBS is a critical part of the solution. Agriculture is the sector of the economy for which the problem is the worst. Fifty to 75 percent of farm workers are undocumented. As internal enforcement has stepped up. family farms are going out of business because they cannot find legal workers. This mighty machine we call American agriculture is on a dangerous precipiceperhaps the most dangerous in our history.
Keywords matched
undocumented immigration immigrants border enforcement illegal immigration

Classification

Also mentioned
Latino
Sentiment
Mixed
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
90%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Economic contributor Legal / procedural Humanitarian

Speaker & context

Speaker
LARRY CRAIG
Party
R
Chamber
S
State
ID
Gender
M
Date
2005-04-19
Speech ID
1090021474
Paragraph
#1
← Prev Next →