I had an intern in my office from Rwanda. She fled during the genocide in 1994. She then came to this country as a refugee and became a legal permanent resident. It took her a year to get all her paperwork for becoming a legal resident and she will probably have to wade through similar bureaucracy to become a citizen as well. It frustrates me that people like her follow the rules and have to wait in 51. Pt. 5 6753 the lines and wait for all the paperwork to be processed. while the illegal aliens can sneak into our country. and then. if they do apply for legal status. they slow down the process for those who came here legally. Not only does AgJOBS reward lawbreakers. It also robs many Americans of jobs they are willing to do. Roy Beck from Numbers USA in his testimony on March 24. 2004. before the Subcommittee on Immigration. Border Security and Claims. quoted Alan Oreenspan from February of last year as saying that America has an "oversupply of lowskilled. loweducated workers." In fact. according to Mr. Becks testimony. the Bureau of Labor Statistics reports that the number of unemployed Americans includes a majority of workers without a high school diploma. Basically. we have a great supply of lower educated American workers without jobs. while ironically. the main purpose of the AgJOBS bill is to bring in loweducated. lowskilled foreign workers for jobs that these Americans are able and willing to fill. A recent article from March 31 of this year in the San Diego UnionTribune entitled "Importing a Peasant Class". written by Jerry Kammer. emphasizes this point by saying: Nearly two decades after a sweeping amnesty for illegal immigrants [referring to the 1986 Amnesty] gave Gerardo Jimenez a ticket out of a San Diego County avocado orchard. he worries that the unyielding tide of lowwage workers from Latin America might pull the economic rug out from under his feet. Jimenez. who is from Mexico and supervises a drywall crew that worked all winter remodeling an office building three blocks from the White House says. "There are too many people coming." The article goes on to say: Jimenezs concern reflects an ambivalence about immigration among established immigrants in America. It also challenges a key assumption of President Bushs proposal for a massive new guestworker program: that the United States has a dearth of lowskill workers. This is not true. we do not have a dearth of lowskill workers. Not only does S. 359 keep able Americans from performing these jobs: it also drives down wages and stifles innovation and technology for these jobs. The same San Diego UnionTribune article I just quoted from continues saying: In Atlanta. house painter Molses Milano says competition for jobs is so stiff among Immigrants that house painters wages have been flat since he came to the United States in the late 1980. Theyre still $9 an hour. he said. which would mean theyve actually fallen significantly when adjusted for inflation. And yet many more aspiring house painters arrive every day from Latin America. Similar concerns can be heard throughout lowwage industries that Latino immigrants have come to dominate during recent decades. including housekeeping. landscaping. janitorial. chicken processing. meat packing. restaurants. hotels and fast food. The article goes on to say: Jimenez says his company competes for contracts against subcontractors using illegal workers who are prepared to work for less and who dont expect health insurance. overtime or other employment benefits. "It puts pressure on his employer to cut labor costs. he said." Jimenez explains why the migrants come and how it hurts current immigrants: "The migrants come because of hunger. because of necessity . . . but I would benefit if someone imposed order." he says. "My work would be worth more." Jimenez says that he wont be able to compete with companies that hire illegal workers so that they can pay lower wages. Not only are workers like Jimenez facing tough competition from companies who hire illegals. but a GAO study from 1988 found that other fields. such as cleaning office buildings. were also experiencing lower wages and more competition as a result of foreign workers. Cleaning office buildings used to pay a decent wage. however as more foreign workers entered the field. wages. benefits and working conditions began to collapse. Other laborintensive fields. such as the construction and the meatpacking industry. have also experienced a drop in pay after an influx of foreign workers. By allowing employers to flood the labor market with foreign workers in these sectors. wages and working conditions have gone down drastically and made these jobs much less attractive to American workers. while making them much more attractive to alien workers. As for stifling technological advances. according to a February 9. 2004. article appearing in National Review: the huge supply of lowwage illegal aliens encourages American farmers to lag technologically behind farmers in other countries. The article continues: Raisin production in California still requires that grapes be cut off by hand and manually turned on the drying tray. In other countries. farmers use a laborsaving technique called drying on the vine. A cutoff of the illegalalien flow would encourage American farmers to adopt many of these technological innovations. and come up with new ones. Another. and possibly more important problem with S. 359. is the risk it poses to our homeland security. It has some of the same loopholes that the 1986 Immigration Reform and Control Act. IRCA. contained. It also overwhelms the already burdened immigration system. not to mention that there are no criminal or terrorist records for these people. For example. an Egyptian illegal immigrant named Mahmud Abouhalima came to America on a tourist visa in 1985. The visa expired in 1986. but Abouhalima stayed here. working illegally as a cab driver. Abouhalima received permanent residency. a green card. in 1988. after winning amnesty under the 1986 IRCA law. Although he had never worked in agriculture in the United States. Abouhalima acquired legal status through the special agricultural workers programwhich is essentially what the AgJobs bill does.
Keywords matched
green card Immigration immigration illegal immigrants immigrants refugee visa illegal immigrant Border Security Immigrants illegal aliens migrants