Session #109 · 2005–07

Speech #1090021388

This bill does not help them one bit. This bill does not provide a database of workers who are actually authorized to work and who are legally present in the country. My point is. there are a lot of problems that confront our national security. a lot of problems that confront our immigration system that need to be addressed that are not addressed in this legislation. To the contrary. rather than trying to address immigration reform comprehensively. rather than trying to improve our border security. our homeland security. by knowing who is in our country and why. rather than providing us a better means of identifying those who. although they begin in this country legally. overstay their time and become part of the population that is here illegally. rather than help employers. this bill does none of that. Instead. what it does is it deals with one segment of the industry that has grown to depend on undocumented workers. and that is the agriculture industry. While I am sympathetic to their concerns. the problem is that it is only one of the industries that relies on undocumented workers. You could as easily file a bill and rather than call it an AgJOBS bill. you could call it a restaurant workers bill. or a residential construction workers bill. or a hotel workers bill. or any one of the number of different industries that has. over time. grown to depend on approximately 6 million people who constitute the illegal workforce currently in the United States. This bill does not purport to deal with any of those other industries and thus chooses one over the other in a way that I think violates one of the fundamental principles of American law. and that is that persons similarly situated ought to be treated as equally as possible and not in any favorable or discriminatory fashion. So I think this bill. as premature as it is. as well intended as it may be. does not help us solve a lot of the problems that can only be addressed by comprehensive immigration reform. It actually does harm by violating some of our basic principles of equal justice under the law. It is important we deal with these problems. I failed to mention one of the problems is we have approximately 400.000 absconders present in the country now and we simply do not have the adequate human or other resources necessary to find out where they are and to show them the way out of the country. Among these absconders. unlike the rest of the population I mentioned. the some 10 million people. are individuals who have been convicted of serious crimes. about 80.000 of them. and who simply have melted into the landscape. As I say. we have about 400.000 absconders. including those 80.000. the difference being those who have simply exhausted all means of appeal and review in our immigration system. who are under final orders of deportation. but who. rather than be deported. have simply gone underground. Here again. this is another issue this bill does not deal with that comprehensive immigration reform would and that we should. What I fear will happen. because it may be tempting to try to fix our immigration problems on a piecemeal basis. is piecemeal solutions and efforts will risk undermining the larger effort and the need to enact comprehensive reform. Indeed. I would venture a guess that if the AgJOBS bill were successful. or even if the alternative offered by the Senator from Georgia and the Senator from Arizona were to be successful. there would be many in this Chamber. and perhaps around this country. who would say: OK. now we have finished that job. We do not need to look at any further immigration reform. The only problem with that is they would be wrong. given the glaring problems that do exist in our country and the challenges to our national security and our ability to look ourselves in the mirror and say. yes. we are a nation of laws. when. in fact. we have such lawlessness existing among us for any one of us to see. if we take the time to look at it. Well. besides dealing with one industry. the AgJOBS bill also has some very troublesome provisions which I think undermine its claimed status as a temporary worker provision. Indeed. an estimated 860.000 illegal alien agricultural workers could qualify. and it also permits them to bring their spouses and children. which could bring the total number of AgJOBS beneficiaries to as many as 3 million people. Now. the interesting thing about that is it does not stop at the people who are already here who came into the country in violation of our laws. Another startling provision of this bill actually invites back to the United States certain aliens who were here illegally and who performed the requisite 100 hours of agricultural work between July 2003 and December 2004 but who have already left. These aliens would be allowed. under this AgJOBS bill. to drop off a "preliminary application" at a designated port of entry along the southern land border. pick up a work permit. and reenter the United States. So not only are we dealing with people who are here now but people who were here illegally and who have left. We are now saying: Come on back and pick up a work permit and reenter this pathway toward full American citizenship ahead of all of the other people who are playing by the rules and waiting in line. That is wrong. Another provision of this bill which I have some concerns about is entitled "Eligibility for Legal Services." which requires free. federally funded legal counsel be affordedthat is. paid forby American taxpayer dollars through
Keywords matched
undocumented border security deported immigration illegal alien deportation work permit

Classification

Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Economic threat Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
JOHN CORNYN
Party
R
Chamber
S
State
TX
Gender
M
Date
2005-04-19
Speech ID
1090021388
Paragraph
#1
← Prev Next →