Session #109 · 2005–07

Speech #1090021350

Coming from a very heavy agriculture area. as I do. these people for the most part who are here working in agriculture are here for the reason they want to improve the quality of life for themselves as well as their families. They are basically lawabiding people who are simply hard workers and are here because they have that opportunity to better themselves in this country versus their native country. But still. are we going to recognize those folks for what they areand that is an illegal alienor are we going to grant them this legal status after being here for 32 months? I do not think the American people ever intended for the Constitution of the United States. and for us operating under that Constitution. to grant legal status to anybody who breaks the law. to come into this country. and who may break the law not once. not twice. but three times during that 31/2month period under the AgJOBS bill. as they can do. and get legal status. I cannot conceive that America wants us to enact that type of legislation. A basic difference between the AgJOBS bill and the ChamblissKyl amendment relative to those issues is we do not put anybody on a path to legal status. We grant them temporary status under the H2A bill. If the farmer comes in and says. "I need 100 workers for 90 days to work on my farm. and here is what they are going to do." we will have that application processed in a streamlined fashion. compared to the way the application would have to be processed today. and those workers can come in. and whether they are cutting lettuce or cutting cabbage or picking cucumbers. they will be able to come in for that 100 days. and at the end of that 100 days. they will return to their native land. If there are other operations. other farming operations. whether it is a landscaper or somebody in the nursery business. that need individuals 12 months out of the year. they will have the opportunity under our bill to apply for the blue cardagain. a temporary status. It must be applied for by the employer. not the illegal alien. as you can do under the AgJOBS bill. The employer must make the application for those individuals. No preferential status toward citizenship is given.
Keywords matched
illegal alienor H2A illegal alien

Classification

Sentiment
Mixed
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Economic contributor Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
SAXBY CHAMBLISS
Party
R
Chamber
S
State
GA
Gender
M
Date
2005-04-19
Speech ID
1090021350
Paragraph
#4
← Prev Next →