Session #109 · 2005–07

Speech #1090021267

Mr. President. I first wish to express appreciation to the Senator from Georgia for explaining very well both the need for and the description of the legislation on which we will be voting tomorrow. which is our version of the legislation that will help employers in our agricultural sector by including immigration reform which will make it easier for them to obtain workers from both the illegal immigrants who are in the country today as well as those legal immigrants who would be applying under our legislation. Let me go back to kind of a 30.000foot elevation view here and describe the reasons we put this legislation together and are offering it at this time. As we have said before. the supplemental appropriations bill. which will be debated again tomorrow as well as later today and which will help pay for our war efforts in Iraq and Afghanistan. Is not the appropriate place to be debating immigration. Unfortunately. some of our colleagues saw fit to bring amendments to the Senate floor which related to that subject. One of those amendments is this amendment that deals with agricultural labor. It was at that point that Senator CHAMBLISS and I had no alternative but to present the alternative view of how to serve those agricultural needs. The basic difference between the bill Senator CHAMBLISS just described and the other bill. the bill that is primarily offered by Senators KENNEDY and CRAIG. is the difference between a bill that provides amnesty. in the case of their legislation. for illegal immigrants here. and our bill. which provides the workforce within the legal construct of the law but does not grant amnesty to the illegal immigrants who are here. There are a lot of other differences. but that is the prime difference. Both of us recognize that there is a significant need for a workforce in this country. willing and able to work in agriculture and related occupations. and that cannot be satisfied solely with people who are American citizens today. The difference is in the way we treat those people who are here illegally today. What the Craig and Kennedy legislation does is to grant those people. very early on. a legal status which permits them to become legal permanent residents. "Legal permanent residents" is a term of art under our immigration law. Some people refer to it as a green card. As little as 100 hours work for 31/2 months entitles someone under their legislation to get a green card. A green card is like gold because it enables you to live for the rest of your life in the United States of America and work here. But it also means something else. If you have a green card. you can also apply to become a citizen of the United States of America. It is a wonderful thing for people from other countries to get to be citizens of the United States of America. We are very much in support of immigration to this country. As my grandparents came here and as almost all the rest of us have relatives who came to this country from another country. we all support legal immigration. But we do not believe that great opportunity to become a citizen of the United States should be granted to someone on the basis of their illegality. because they came here illegally. because they used counterfeit documents. because they got a job illegallythat on the basis of those factors they should get an advantage over those who are abiding by the law and who want to become U.S. citizens. It is that with which we disagree.
Keywords matched
illegal immigrants immigrants green card immigration

Classification

Also mentioned
immigrants_general
Sentiment
Mixed
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
95%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Economic contributor Legal / procedural

Speaker & context

Speaker
JON KYL
Party
R
Chamber
S
State
AZ
Gender
M
Date
2005-04-19
Speech ID
1090021267
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →