Session #109 · 2005–07

Speech #1090019946

I rise to oppose this amendment. even though I agree with many of the principles expounded in it. No. 1. to my colleagues on the Judiciary Committee. the sponsors of this amendment. I too. agree. that our immigration system is badly broken. It does fail to serve the interests of our national security and our national economy. We do need to enact the critical appropriations bill to support our troops and help people who are tsunami victims and some other important aspects. At the same time. though. the sense of the Senate really should be directed to the House. For someone like myself. who has a very serious crisis because of something called the H2B visas. which I will explain in more detail at another time. the fact is this is our only vehicle. Immigration. as an issue. was introduced in the supplemental appropriation bill in the House of Representatives with an enormously controversial and prickly concept. the socalled REAL ID card. I know that my colleague from Tennessee has proposed some creative solutions to deal with that. I know that others want to talk about this. If we can talk about comprehensive immigration reform. I am all for it. But the question is. When are we going to do it? It has been over 1.000 days since 9/11. and we have not done comprehensive immigration reform. nor have we looked at what aspects of immigration are working. There are certain aspects that are working in certain areas of the guest worker programs. college students who come from abroad. who work in our country and learn in our country and go back home. what a tremendous exercise in public diplomacy the socalled J visas have accomplished. In my own State. the H2B visa. which allows guest workers to come into this country for seasonal employment to take jobs that are certified as not being held by American workers. with a mandated return to their own home. has worked well. It has worked so well that the cap is now bursting at the seams. I am all for comprehensive immigration reform. but No. 4 says Congress should not short circuit the discussion by attaching amendments to this supplemental. We have had no discussion. There is nothing to short circuit.
Keywords matched
Immigration immigration H2B visa visas

Classification

Target group
Sentiment
Neutral
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
100%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Legal / procedural Economic contributor

Speaker & context

Speaker
BARBARA MIKULSKI
Party
D
Chamber
S
State
MD
Gender
F
Date
2005-04-14
Speech ID
1090019946
Paragraph
#0
← Prev Next →