Session #106 · 1999–2001

Speech #1060108465

Unfortunately. Mr. President. our current asylum and immigration laws have nearly slammed the door shut on victims of persecution. even those who are sure to suffer if returned to their home countries. Current law originates with the passage in 1996 of the Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act. That law was an attempt to combat illegal immigration. But in the process. Congress denied victims of persecution the protection that our nation historically has offered. The current system provides for the immediate deportation of individuals who arrive without travel documents precisely in order. Now. Mr. President. its appropriate that we require these documents. but people who have fled torture and great brutality may not have proper documentation because of the circumstances under which they fled their homelands. As a result. genuine victims of persecution face the risk of being turned away at our borders and put on the next plane back to face imprisonment. torture or death. The 1996 law effectively empowers low level INS officers to summarily make the life and death decision as to whether to deport an asylum seeker. Prior to 1996. those decisions were made by an immigration judge. We must return a judicial role to the review of asylum claims. As my colleagues who were here in 1995 and 1996 may recall. the 1996 law was enacted in reaction to a flurry of concern that our border controls were too lax. The debate on the 1996 law was fueled by legitimate concern over criminals who managed to enter the country and commit acts of terrorism or other crimes. In response. the INS began a sensible tightening of the asylum process. In 1994 and 1995. the INS ceased issuing work authorizations at the border. Instead. asylum seekers had to wait until an adjudication of their case before receiving work authorization. As a result. claims for asylum dropped dramaticallythose who were seeking work but did not have a legitimate fear of persecution were no longer claiming asylum. The INS reforms were effective. But the 1996 law went too far. In our rush to keep undesirable asylum applicants out. Congress created a system where those with bona fide asylum claims face the great risk of being immediately deported to face the wrath of oppressive home governments without a real chance to make their case. Because an INS officer has the authority to deport refugees immediately. with no record keeping requirement. it has been difficult to determine exactly how many genuine refugees with a valid fear of persecution in their home countries have been turned away at our airports and borders as a result of the 1996 law. Organizations like the Lawyers Committee for Human Rights. however. have been able to collect some data on the extent of the problem. One of the most troubling stories is the case of a 21yearold Kosovar Albanian known as "Dem." In October 1998.
Keywords matched
asylum seeker asylum claims Illegal Immigration asylum process immigration deported refugees Immigrant deportation asylum seekers border control asylum applicants illegal immigration

Classification

Target group
Sentiment
Negative
Stereotyping
No
Confidence
95%
Model
gemini-2.0-flash
Framing
Humanitarian Legal / procedural Victim

Speaker & context

Speaker
RUSSELL FEINGOLD
Party
D
Chamber
S
State
WI
Gender
M
Date
1999-11-16
Speech ID
1060108465
Paragraph
#1
← Prev Next →